49 pages • 1 hour read
Sadeqa JohnsonA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Pheby awakes to the smell of smoke. Tommy accidentally set a haystack on fire. Rubin whips Tommy in front of everyone with a hickory branch. After he is finished, Pheby tends to the boy. Tommy gets an infection and fever from his wounds. Pheby is pained when she thinks about how little time she is permitted to spend with her son.
Pheby has three children with Rubin: Hester, Isabel, and Joan. Rubin permits Pheby to read to their three daughters and have them educated, but Pheby must tutor Monroe privately. Monroe asks Pheby if he is enslaved. Pheby admits that everyone at the jail apart from Rubin is enslaved, including her.
Hester and Monroe are close, but each child is raised differently. When Monroe and Hester play a game of hide the puppet, Hester gets frustrated that she cannot find it and begins to cry. Rubin drags Monroe away and beats him. He then forces Monroe to be moved out of the house completely and tells Pheby that Monroe is no longer allowed to spend time with their daughters. Pheby visits Monroe and tells him what her mother Ruth told her: “You his slave in name only, never in your mind, boy. You are meant to see freedom. It is my solemn promise to you” (169). Pheby becomes pregnant again and gives birth to a boy.
Something is not right with Pheby’s son, who Rubin names Rubin, after himself. Pheby uses her mother’s wisdom to care for the boy, but he does not recover. The baby Rubin dies a few days after he is born. Rubin and Pheby grieve his death together.
Pheby is depressed and sick after the loss of her son: “I could feel myself dying, week by week” (177). Monroe, worried about his mother, gives her a bracelet he made from straw. Rubin gives her books as a gift. She absorbs Emma by Jane Austen and Jane Eyre by Charlotte Brontë.
Rubin hires a tutor to educate the girls. Pheby tells July to stay with the girls and listen carefully but keep her face neutral, so no one suspects that she is learning. Sissy assists Pheby in the sewing room to prepare girls for auction. Pheby notices that Sissy is pregnant, and she realizes that she is too is pregnant again. Sissy gives birth to a boy with dark skin.
Pheby meets with Monroe secretly in the barn, just as she used to do with Essex. When they visit, she quizzes her son on his birthday and his knowledge of counting and reading. Monroe develops a skill with horses, like his father, and Pheby tells him that caring for horses is in his blood.
One of Rubin’s enslaved workers named Basil escapes. Pheby is surprised. Basil always seemed docile and submissive toward Rubin. The jailer takes it upon himself to find Basil, and he brutally punishes anyone he suspects of participating in his escape. Pheby gives birth to a fourth daughter, Katherine. While Pheby plays music for more of Rubin’s guests in the tavern, she learns that a young man has been “causing a ruckus” in the North; his name is Essex Henry (185). Essex was arrested and is being brought back to Virginia. Still angry at Basil’s departure, Rubin decides to have Essex sent to his jail so he can make an example of him.
Through the narrative of pain and suffering, there is an undercurrent of resilience and resistance. Through education, the enslaved people in the book are able to defy their enslavers, illustrating Ruth’s statement that their minds can never be enslaved. Pheby ensures that her daughters and Monroe know how to read, write, and calculate. She secures an education for her daughters while tutoring her son in private. She also encourages July to listen to her daughters’ lessons and to ask her if she has questions. When Pheby reads the books Rubin gives her, she broadens her understanding of the world and escapes her life, if only for a few hours. However, Pheby is not able to extend her knowledge to everyone, a fact that will become an important plot point with Sissy later in the novel.
Basil’s escape serves as a reminder that Pheby is not the only one living in conflict with her personal values. Basil appears to be submissive and doting toward Rubin. He escorts Pheby to church services to ensure that she does not escape. When Rubin tells Basil to strap down Tommy so he can be beaten, Basil does so without hesitation. Pheby is surprised when she learns that Basil has escaped: “He had us all fooled” (183). Like Pheby, Basil acted out his part of devoted servant while biding his time to secure his freedom.
For Rubin, the loss of Basil was a personal affront, as Rubin convinces himself that those he exerts power over love him. Basil’s escape feels like a betrayal; it strengthens Rubin’s resolve to keep his thumb on Pheby and his children so that they cannot leave. He sees Pheby as his wife, even as he abuses her and denies her the status available to a loving partner. Sadeqa Johnson shows how The Complex Relationship Between Submission and Defiance destroys everyone involved, the abuser and the abused. Rubin is unable to understand love or experience it fully because he cannot untangle love from power.
Through Monroe, Johnson illustrates The Pervasive Trauma of Enslavement. Rubin treats Monroe harshly and differently than his sisters; he is abused and taken away from Pheby. Pheby is constantly mindful that Monroe’s existence at Lapier’s jail is fragile. When he plays with his sisters, the distinction between the way they’re treated is further highlighted. Monroe understands that, even though his sisters are also enslaved, his status is different from the rest of his family. Despite his mother’s efforts, everything in Monroe’s life affirms that the world sees him as less than human. The grief of his mother and Rubin over the loss of their son serves as a further reminder that he is the unwanted offspring that Rubin must tolerate.
American Civil War
View Collection
Challenging Authority
View Collection
Community Reads
View Collection
Contemporary Books on Social Justice
View Collection
Memorial Day Reads
View Collection
Military Reads
View Collection
Popular Book Club Picks
View Collection
Power
View Collection
Sexual Harassment & Violence
View Collection
The Best of "Best Book" Lists
View Collection