50 pages • 1 hour read
Robert DugoniA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide discusses depictions of drug and alcohol misuse, post-traumatic stress disorder, and wartime atrocities that feature in the source text.
The World Played Chess concerns the coming of age of the three main characters.
William’s coming of age is abrupt, almost instantaneous, occurring, as it does, overnight, with his first direct experience of war. Forced into a premature adulthood, the war in Vietnam robs William of his childhood and dehumanizes him into a killer. He learns at an early age how to value his mortality, but his experiences in the war also alienate him from his life in the United States. In this way, William’s experience is representative of an entire generation of young men who participated in a conflict in which they themselves had no direct stake and who returned home to face the stigma of having been veterans in an unpopular war. Like William, the many men who experienced PTSD after the war found no sympathy or understanding for a mental health condition that as yet had not been identified as such. Considered unstable and violent, such men were often shunned, and some used drugs and alcohol to cope with their ongoing trauma. In effect, then, the Vietnam War prevented anything like the process of coming of age, and only when—and if—veterans with trauma could eventually find help nearly a decade after the war was over and PTSD was recognized for what it is could they begin the belated growth into responsibility and humanity, as William himself does. When Vincent first meets him in the summer of 1979, however, that journey has not yet begun for William. Only when he finds a sympathetic, unjudgmental ear in the young Vincent can William find support in his coming-of-age story and begin to move forward with his life.
Just as Vincent helps William grow into the person he could be (albeit this help is unwitting), so William helps Vincent mature during the summer after he graduates from high school. Although William can be misguided when he sets out to teach life lessons—as in the incident with the woman in the car—he does convey through his stories about Vietnam the reality of mortality and the value of life, which teenage boys hardly consider. Nor has Vincent up to this point. At first, he wants to fit in with the men on the construction site and continue to party with his friends. But being a happy-go-lucky partier is at odds with the responsibility that comes with adulthood, and as Vincent matures over the summer and comes to take pleasure in hard work, he begins letting go of his youthful friendships and getting closer to William. In the process, he sees the effects of the Vietnam War on this veteran, who misuses drugs and alcohol and can even become violent at times, yet Vincent admires William’s ability to survive and recognizes life lessons in William’s experiences. William fought in a war he didn’t believe in, so Vincent decides to stop getting into fights he doesn’t believe in just because he thinks getting in a fight makes for a good “manly” story. Essentially, Vincent learns that performative masculinity is destructive.
Beau’s coming-of-age story resembles that of his father—and to that extent differs profoundly from William’s. Although Vincent and Beau do have a brush with mortality, this occurs due to the harmfulness of drunk driving, not the exigencies of war. For Beau, however, the loss of his best friend in such an accident is profoundly traumatic (and suggests in hindsight why William was advised not to make friends with his fellow soldiers in Vietnam). He feels as though he loses part of himself in that accident and could very well become trapped in a cycle of survivor’s guilt—again, nothing like William’s, but still enough to prevent him from developing his own identity and shaping his own future. As Vincent passes on the life lessons that he learned from William to his son, he furthers the positive possibilities of coming of age that emerge from William’s tragic story.
Empathy and understanding are important in The World Played Chess, including in the situations in which both are absent—namely, during the Vietnam War and its aftermath. In order both to kill the “enemy” and to survive in Vietnam, William has to be devoid of empathy toward and understanding of others. This amounts to dehumanizing himself and others to the point that he casually shoots at and kills an innocent Vietnamese child.
When William returns from the war, the trauma he experienced there—that is, the dehumanization of everyone in every sense of the term—persists. This trauma is reinforced by the lack of empathy and understanding by American civilians who not only object to the war, but also blame veterans in general for specific atrocities committed there and who stigmatize those who must deal with the ongoing trauma of the war. William becomes alienated from his society and has no tools to rebuild his self-esteem and deal with his trauma and guilt. His society turns its back against him, leaving William to fend for himself. This eventually leads William to start a new life in California, where he is susceptible to drug and alcohol addiction due to his continuing undiagnosed and untreated PTSD. This alcohol and drug addiction, which for some veterans is the only way to cope, perpetuates a cycle of self-destruction and alienation from a society that shuns them, not recognizing what is a form of self-medication, however self-destructive that may be.
What William needs more than anything is empathy, which he receives from the unlikely source of a teenager who has no idea about war, but who listens to William and takes in what he says without judging him. Thus, William starts talking about the war in ways he’s never been able to before, and while this impacts his depression and addiction, it also shows him that if Vincent is willing to listen without judgment, then other people may be as well. This summer of empathy inspires William to find formal help for his addiction, which also leads him to therapy for his PTSD. William finds empathy for himself because of the empathy Vincent had extended to him.
Todd is also an example of someone who doesn’t receive enough empathy. When Vincent first meets Todd, Vincent is intimated by Todd’s gait. He perceives Todd as tough with a domineering swagger. Only later does he learn that Todd actually limps. Todd doesn’t have a natural tough-guy gait. He limps because he was so forlorn and destroyed in Vietnam that he convinced a drunk comrade to beat his leg so badly that he would be dismissed from combat. Though this actually saved Todd’s life, Todd is forced to live the rest of his life with the physical manifestation of his trauma in Vietnam. People don’t know the gritty reality of Todd’s past. It’s a difficult story to tell, and a difficult story to hear.
Vincent often runs into empathy overload. For example, when his son Beau’s friend Chris dies, Vincent takes a break from reading William’s journal because he can’t handle so much pain. All people have boundaries and a limit for empathy. But the practice of empathy is the practice of patience. Vincent returns to William’s journal when he’s ready. Therefore, he doesn’t fake his empathy.
In this novel, Dugoni emphasizes the importance of empathy and understanding. When we are empathetic listeners, we learn more about the world around us. We can also help push people to acknowledge their vulnerability and seek help. Empathy is a way of restructuring humanization after trauma.
In The World Played Chess, Dugoni explores how trauma can paradoxically lead to growth.
The tragic and pointless death of his best friend, Chris, in a drunk-driving accident traumatizes Beau. His grief for Chris’s death is compounded by the fact that they had been so close that their identities had been intertwined, and now Beau must figure out who he is. At first, that means being pulled in two directions—on the one hand, imitating Chris and trying out for a college football team as Chris would have done, on the other, thinking he wants total independence from his family and going far away to college. But after he does not make the cut, he reconsiders his commitment to football and realizes that he can neither live Chris’s life nor honor him by playing a game. Along with this maturation comes the realization that he need not cut ties with his family to become independent. California is a big state. He can go to college far enough away from home to have the autonomy he desires, close enough to have support when he wants and needs it.
Vincent experiences second-hand trauma from William’s stories of the war. Although it is difficult to comprehend the horrors of war that William and hundreds of thousands of young men suffered in Vietnam without having experienced them, Vincent is such an empathetic listener that William’s stories can make him physically sick, but they also make him wiser. Thus, when his friend drives drunk, nearly killing Vincent and others in the car, Vincent’s fear at that moment is only a very small taste of the fear that William lived with for over a year, but it is enough not only to make his survival instinct kick in—as it did for William—but also to prod him into more adult, more responsible behavior.
For William, growth threatens to be cut off by trauma. The PTSD he experiences holds him back, making him both relive the war and attempt to deaden the pain of doing so through drugs and alcohol. Ten years after the war, he is still in it. Only when he can talk about it to an empathetic listener can he begin to get some distance from it and begin a journey toward healing and growth, through which he will ultimately help other veterans do as well.
By Robert Dugoni
Family
View Collection
Fathers
View Collection
Friendship
View Collection
Historical Fiction
View Collection
Memorial Day Reads
View Collection
Military Reads
View Collection
Popular Book Club Picks
View Collection
Popular Study Guides
View Collection
Sexual Harassment & Violence
View Collection
Truth & Lies
View Collection
Vietnam War
View Collection
War
View Collection