logo

49 pages 1 hour read

Alka Joshi

The Secret Keeper of Jaipur

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2021

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 3, Chapters 8-16Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 3: “Two Days Before the Collapse”

Part 3, Chapter 8 Summary: “Lakshmi”

One day, Lakshmi is working in the clinic when two children arrive with an unusual patient—an injured sheep. While examining the animal, Lakshmi notices that the wool has been sheared away and then stitched back up: “The fleece appears to have a clean slit, like a welt pocket on a coat. The wound is underneath the fleece. How could that have happened?” (102). Nimmi is enlisted to help translate what the children have to say about the animal. Apparently, it was wandering alone out in the countryside. Nimmi’s hesitation leads Lakshmi to believe that she’s concealing some information.

That night, when Lakshmi tells Jay about the incident, he seems concerned and says that they must go to Nimmi’s hut immediately. Jay knows that the animal was being used to smuggle gold bars into the country. Nimmi, too, is aware that smugglers recruit shepherds to transport their cargo this way. She says that the sheep belongs to her brother Vinnay and that the smugglers will kill him if they think he has stolen their gold. She’s getting ready to go look for Vinnay, but Jay persuades her to wait until morning. When Lakshmi and Jay check in on her after daybreak, she and her children are already gone.

Part 3, Chapter 9 Summary: “Malik”

Back in Jaipur, Malik is working in the accounting department for Hakeem and discovers some odd discrepancies related to the theater building project: “The amount Singh-Sharma Construction has spent on cement is three times the sum the firm has spent on bricks. So why would the latest invoices show the opposite?” (115).

Later, Malik shows the problem to Ravi, who casually reverses the numbers in the ledger to make the problem go away: “Ravi shrugs. ‘Look, there’s no need to complicate things. Hakeem needs the numbers to match. They’ll match. End of story’” (118). On the spur of the moment, Ravi invites Malik to dinner that night at a fancy restaurant.

Ravi’s wife, Sheela, joins them there for the meal. Afterward, Ravi makes the excuse that he has a late-night business meeting even though he’s planning to meet his mistress. He sends Malik to accompany his wife home. Sheela invites her escort in for a drink. Although Malik feels attracted to Sheela, who might be trying to seduce him, he escapes before anything happens. Back at home, he feels as guilty as if he’d actually cheated on Nimmi.

Part 3, Chapter 10 Summary: “Nimmi”

Nimmi has gone in search of her brother in the foothills of the Himalayas. She eventually finds him unconscious, clearly injured from a fall. When she struggles to revive him, Vinnay speaks briefly, pointing to a book of matches in his pocket. He’s concerned about the gold and the missing sheep but dies before he can say more. At that moment, Lakshmi comes riding up on her horse. The two women conclude that the shepherd fell down a crevasse and broke his back and legs. He might have been lying there for a few days.

Nimmi worries about the rest of the flock. She will need to round them up so that the smugglers won’t come after Vinnay’s family if the gold goes missing. Lakshmi agrees to help her. They load Vinnay’s body on the horse’s back and take him back to the hospital for cremation. Nimmi then gives Lakshmi the matchbox that her brother had: “‘Canara Private Enterprises Limited, Shimla,’ she reads aloud” (137). Lakshmi concludes that this must be the smuggling contact.

On their way back home, they encounter the rest of the missing flock. Rounding them up, the women herd them back to town. Nimmi thinks, “A month ago, I was still angry with Lakshmi Kumar for telling me what to do [...] for being so bloody competent. But now I just feel a sense of relief that someone—anyone—is willing to take charge and help” (139).

Part 3, Chapter 11 Summary: “Lakshmi”

After arriving at the hospital, Lakshmi looks for Jay. He suggests penning the sheep on the hospital grounds for a few days, where they can eat the grass. After getting Nimmi and the children settled, Lakshmi mounts her horse and goes in search of Canara Private Enterprises. When she arrives there, Lakshmi notices that the company is engaged in making bricks. She meets the contact for the smuggling business, who insists that he only wants the gold, not the sheep. Lakshmi promises to bring the cargo the following day. This commitment means that she, Jay, and Nimmi must stay up all night to shear the sheep.

Part 3, Chapter 12 Summary: “Malik”

In Jaipur, Malik calls on a jeweler named Moti-Lal, whom he knows from the old days. The jeweler’s wife was one of Lakshmi’s first customers. Today, Malik wants to buy a gold necklace for the old woman who cared for him as a boy and another necklace for Nimmi. This gesture alleviates some of Malik’s guilt about his flirtation with Sheela.

Part 3, Chapter 13 Summary: “Nimmi”

At home, Nimmi has already begun shearing the single sheep that was treated at the hospital. Lakshmi arrives and says that they must shear the entire flock that night. Nimmi thinks, “I notice the tired lines under her eyes. She’s done so much already—trekking up and down the mountains, carting my brother’s body to Shimla, riding to that business on the outskirts of town” (164). Nimmi is touched by Lakshmi’s kindness to someone who isn’t family.

Part 3, Chapter 14 Summary: “Lakshmi”

That night, Lakshmi goes to the pasture with Nimmi; Jay insists on coming along too. They must shear 39 sheep to recover 20 pounds of gold bars. Afterward, Nimmi says that the sheep must be completely shorn to remove the telltale signs of the pockets in their flanks. She’ll keep the wool and sell it later.

Back at home, Jay confesses that he started asking around about any smuggling in the vicinity. Lakshmi fears that his curiosity might alert the police: “If the authorities were to find those half-shorn sheep at the bottom of the lower pasture, we’d all three of us be implicated” (170). Furthermore, the Indian government runs on nepotism and corruption. Lakshmi fears that the police might be on the payroll of the gold smugglers. This means that they must get the sheep completely shorn the following night.

The next morning, Lakshmi arrives at Canara to deliver the gold bars. She finds a woman at work making clay bricks, all of which have hollow indentations in the center. This seems odd, though the worker doesn’t know why they’re shaped this way. Just then, the smuggling contact arrives to collect the gold. Two bricks are missing, but Lakshmi bluffs and says that she kept those as payment. She hastily departs before the smuggler demands the missing bricks, and Jay is waiting outside to escort her home.

Part 3, Chapter 15 Summary: “Nimmi”

Nimmi and her children are now staying at Lakshmi’s house for protection. Late that night, Nimmi, Jay, and Lakshmi sneak out to complete their shearing operation. Hours later, they’re almost done when Jay hears someone approaching. He tells Lakshmi to hide and asks Nimmi to accompany him to see what the problem is.

The local police captain and his team are making a night patrol. Jay pretends that he is having a lover’s tryst with Nimmi in the pasture. He bribes the police captain to ignore the rendezvous and not tell his wife. Nimmi drops a casual hint that she has heard gossip about a smuggling operation at Canara Enterprises. The police leave without even noticing the sheep.

Part 3, Chapter 16 Summary: “Lakshmi”

On the way home, no one speaks about the awkward pretense of an affair. Lakshmi feels insecure and jealous: “I saw the way that Jay reacted when confronted by the captain, pretending—so convincingly—to be having an affair with Nimmi. Even I almost believed him” (184).

Back at the house, Lakshmi receives a late-night phone call from her friend Kanta in Jaipur. She learns that the new theater has just collapsed. Malik is safe, but Kanta’s husband is being blamed for the tragedy: “The biggest project for the palace so far—the maharani invested all that money to build it! And Manu was in charge of it. He’s beside himself! Says he has no idea how it could have happened” (185). Because Manu was the project manager, everyone’s pointing a finger at him. Realizing that her friend needs her, Lakshmi promises to take the morning train to Jaipur.

Before Lakshmi leaves, Nimmi confronts her angrily. She blames the older woman for putting Malik in danger by sending him to Jaipur: “He needs to live his own life now. He deserves to make his own way in the world. It’s time for you to let him go. He needs to hear it from you” (189). Lakshmi is taken aback by the accusation that she’s controlling Malik for his own good: “I feel hollow—like a reed before the henna paste fills its core. I don’t know what to say, or what to think. I can neither speak, nor move” (190).

Part 3, Chapters 8-16 Analysis

This segment represents Part 3 of the book and covers events two days before the theater collapse. It consists of two parallel mystery investigations and principally highlights The Power of Secrets and this theme’s associated symbol, gold. In Shimla, Nimmi discovers a sheep from her brother Vinnay’s flock that was used to smuggle gold bars into the country. This small discovery soon escalates into a full-blown crisis when she finds Vinnay’s body after a fatal fall in the mountains. He leaves behind a single clue—a matchbox from Canara Private Enterprises.

This plot twist greatly diminishes Nimmi’s hostility toward Lakshmi. As she did in the preceding book in the series, Lakshmi takes charge of a difficult situation and resolves it. She helps Nimmi find a place for Vinnay’s flock and a way to remove the smuggled gold without anyone noticing. Then, she visits Canara and negotiates the surrender of the gold without the smugglers becoming suspicious that their operation has been compromised. Nimmi notes the effort that Lakshmi is willing to expend on her behalf. To this point, the girl has always identified herself as an “outsider,” a member of a nomadic group who has no expectation that anyone else will be kind to her. Lakshmi’s behavior leads Nimmi to believe that she might have found a new place for herself in the hearts of the Kumar family and in Shimla.

The gold symbol carries through to events transpiring at the same time in Jaipur. Malik’s brief visit to Moti-Lal’s jewelry shop helps uncover the gold fever that fuels the smuggling operation. Malik himself uses gold as a way to assuage his guilt, buying a necklace for Nimmi to absolve himself of his short-lived attraction toward Sheela. He recalls Sheela’s contemptuous behavior toward him when he was alone and unhoused. The fact that she doesn’t recognize him as that penniless orphan helps Malik see himself as belonging to the upper crust where Sheela has always been. Part of his attraction toward her is the confirmation that he has arrived. He can now pass convincingly for a member of high society.

Aside from this brief reference to gold, which connects both narrative streams, Malik is preoccupied with an investigation of his own. While working in the accounting department for the persnickety Hakeem, he notices discrepancies in the charges for bricks and cement. At this point, nothing indicates that a disproportionate amount of cement is required to fill the holes in the bricks that were previously filled with smuggled gold. Malik has just stumbled onto a new secret that is unrelated to events from the previous book. He doesn’t yet know the connection to the events unfolding in a sheep pasture in Shimla, but subsequent chapters will make that connection clear.

Although this segment supposedly covers events prior to the theater collapse, a brief section at the end of Chapter 16 moves forward in time to describe the immediate aftermath of the collapse. Kanta calls Lakshmi to tell her about the theater tragedy and also that everyone is blaming her husband for the faulty balcony construction. As is typical of Lakshmi, she’s ready to spring into action to help a friend and immediately makes plans to travel to Jaipur.

This turn of events provides the pretext for Nimmi to stage a confrontation with her new benefactor. The resentment that has been simmering comes boiling to the surface when Nimmi learns that Malik might have died in the theater collapse. To Nimmi’s way of thinking, Lakshmi’s decision to send Malik to Jaipur put him in danger in the first place. Because Nimmi has already exercised one of her Personal Life Choices (another of the book’s main themes), she can clearly see that Malik hasn’t. He’s still tied to tradition and his gratitude for Lakshmi’s guidance. Because Malik isn’t ready to defy his guardian, Nimmi takes on the role of pointing out Lakshmi’s unawareness. The latter seems thunderstruck when the girl can see what the former henna artist didn’t recognize in herself. Malik must make his own choices in life. Further, Lakshmi must guide him to those choices by removing her own wishes from the equation. Nimmi says, “‘Mrs. Kumar, you have to let him go. You have to.’ She opens her mouth to say more, but nothing comes. She merely stares into my eyes, as if she wants to reach the part of me that I don’t allow anyone to see” (189).

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text