104 pages • 3 hours read
Elizabeth George SpeareA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more. For select classroom titles, we also provide Teaching Guides with discussion and quiz questions to prompt student engagement.
Rosh assigns Joel the task of gathering information about the attendees of a banquet. The half-Jew appointed to rule over them, Herod Antipas, is entertaining a special legation from Rome, and the richest men in Capernaum will attend. Joel is the only one who can get the information. Daniel struggles with envy as he, Joel, and Malthace excitedly complete each other’s sentences. They decide that Joel will sell fish to the kitchen servants at the party. Daniel feels an unexpected misgiving and tells Joel that Rosh has no right to order him—Joel has a family and a future to think about. Malthace suggests that she dress up as Joel as they often did as children. That way, she can walk out of the city with Daniel and no one will suspect him. Malthace has wanted to visit Leah for days, so they head there. As Joel and Malthace relish in their conspiracy, Daniel’s doubts subside
The next morning, Joel is dressed as a barefoot fisherman, and Malthace is dressed as Joel. Malthace hopes to avoid Jesus, who she knows will disapprove of her lie. Malthace suggests that Jesus might mean the kingdom will come without fighting—maybe the Romans could understand that God sees into their hearts and loves them. Daniel angrily tells Malthace that a girl can’t understand such things. They cross paths with two Roman soldiers who ask them to carry their heavy packs. When Daniel spits on the ground, Malthace awkwardly lifts one pack. Picking up the other, Daniel wants to weep with shame. At first, Daniel wishes Malthace would stumble and fall for tricking him into humiliation. However, Daniel is flooded with shame when he sees Malthace struggle. After a mile, the soldiers let them go on account of Malthace’s slow pace. Though Malthace scolds Daniel for nearly losing his head, she admits that she is proud of his courage. Daniel is taken by surprise: He has never been praised and doesn’t know what to make of it.
Back at Simon’s home, Leah immediately recognizes Malthace. Leah is a different girl in Malthace’s presence, and Daniel finds excuses to watch them. During their afternoon meal, Malthace acts naturally, as though she has forgotten her luxurious lifestyle. When Leah stares through the door and blushes, Daniel is angered to see the soldier and slams the door. Daniel gives Malthace the brooch he crafted as a gift, admitting that it stands for their oath. Awestruck, Malthace believes Daniel should be a silversmith. As they head back, Malthace shares that Leah changes each time she visits. Daniel discusses Leah’s bad days, grateful for the chance to share his burden.
When Malthace asks if a physician has seen Leah, Daniel says that a man with magic healing could not do anything because Leah does not want to be made well. Malthace remembers how Jesus always asks if someone wants to be whole before healing them and asks Daniel if he has considered taking Leah to Jesus. Daniel questions whether healing is actually good for everyone and if bringing Leah back into the world is worth it. Tears spring to Malthace’s eyes as she describes the surrounding beauty. Suddenly aware of Daniel’s longing look and their joined hands, Malthace pulls away.
Daniel learns through the villagers that Rosh robbed five of the wealthiest houses in Capernaum. Though Daniel is happy at first, he feels let down by the end of the day. He and the boys expected something more noble and worthy of the cause from Joel’s enterprise than a looting. He wonders if Joel thinks the danger and the loss of hours from study was worth it. At their meeting that night, Joel shares that he not only furnished all the information for the raid, but even returned in the morning to the robbed houses to hear the full story from unsuspecting servants. Joel wants to continue using his disguise to obtain information. Daniel’s boys question what Rosh will do with the money until Daniel tells them to leave it to Rosh. Though the boys are loyal, Daniel is not satisfied with his own answer. Rosh’s name is the talk of the town as the villagers debate on whether Rosh is a defender of the Jews or has turned against them.
Joel throws himself into the role of a fish peddler, becoming experienced in interpreting pieces of gossip. Rosh utilizes Joel’s intelligence reports to strike far and wide. The boys feel no pity for the victims—any traitor is fair prey. Rosh’s boldness forces caravans and travelers to increase their protection. When some of the mountain outlaws fall into Roman hands, Daniel’s boys are admitted into Rosh’s active service. Daniel watches their childish exploits with dismay—he dreamed of raising a band to plan, train, and grow strong for a more noble purpose. However, he is proud when his boys find a catapult on the side of the road. They decide to take it apart at night, breaking and carrying away its planks and crossbeams. By the next morning, the catapult is gone without a trace.
Wild with success, the boys swagger through the village. Daniel warns them that they can’t strike now. Joel sends warnings from the city that the Romans are strengthening their forces. A new detachment of soldiers has joined the garrison at Capernaum, and the patrol on the roads has doubled. When Rosh’s band snares three more of the town’s sheep, the villagers request Daniel to get a message to Rosh—he is to leave their sheep alone. Daniel quietly asks if they begrudge a sheep now and then to a man who would give his life for their freedom.
The men, however, have a different perspective: “He’s free up there. Free from the taxes that bleed us dry. Free to play with the Romans while we stand and take the punishment” (194). When a farmer finds his crop plundered and ruined, Daniel takes the warning to Rosh. Rosh laughs in his face, telling Daniel that their only purpose is to raise food for men who fight. When Daniel tells Rosh that the villagers will appeal to the centurion for protection, Rosh says to let them get a taste of the mountain. Daniel realizes that they must hurry—the whole village is turning against Rosh, and they might never follow him.
One afternoon, Daniel sees a disguised Malthace running to his shop. The Roman legionaries suspected the centurion’s kitchen slaves and took Joel when he came to the door. Joel is sentenced to live in the galleys. Daniel reassures Malthace that Rosh will know what to do. As Leah watches from behind her loom, Daniel wonders how much she understands. He tells Leah to take care of Malthace as he goes up the mountain.
When Daniel reaches the cave, Rosh is disinterested. He grunts that Joel was getting too confident. Daniel tells Rosh that the soldiers won’t be looking for an attack and that they can surprise them on the road if they move fast. Rosh responds that it is not his affair—every man on the mountain is responsible for himself. Enraged, Daniel exclaims that Joel was only following orders and that eight of them took Samson. Rosh reasons that they took Samson from scurvy traders and that the might of Rome is another matter. He can’t spare eight men for someone stupid enough to get caught.
Daniel is taken aback that Rosh would use Joel and let him go without even trying. Rosh reminds Daniel of his soft streak and that he can be of no good to the cause until he is rid of it. Suddenly, the anger clears from Daniel’s mind, and he sees Rosh differently. He asks if Rosh even knows what the cause means. Before Rosh can rebuke him, Daniel announces that he is not one of Rosh’s men any longer. He knows he is done with the mountain forever and leaves. When Joktan joins him, Daniel is disappointed that he has not gotten the chance to say a final goodbye to Samson. Daniel has the uncanny feeling that someone is following them.
When Daniel’s boys meet up, they are angry that Rosh will do nothing. Daniel feels that they trusted him and he failed them all. The boys say they can do without Rosh—unlike his selfish philosophy, they stand for each other. Daniel has a plan to get Joel back: They will spread out on the cliffs surrounding the path and throw rocks. The Romans won’t expect an attack, and they can take Joel once they stir up confusion. When Daniel says that they need a leader, the boys proudly proclaim that they have already chosen him. Daniel asks for a vote, but no one challenges him. Daniel tells the boys to take all the weapons they have and reminds them of the scriptures Joel always read to them. The same God who strengthened Judas, Jonathan, and Simon will strengthen them, too.
In the time Daniel spends with Malthace, they develop their relationship both romantically and spiritually. Daniel holds deeply patriarchal opinions about women, resorting to the idea that women can’t understand things when he has no better argument to make. Malthace, on the other hand, is intelligent and perceptive. She not only understands and identifies with Daniel and Joel’s vow but is able to identify the true purpose of their cause when it is misplaced. She gives words to Daniel’s secret doubts that Jesus may never want to fight the Romans. Jesus’s teachings have always relied on repentance, love, and acceptance of all. Daniel, too, analyzes the concept of healing—whether healing is always a good thing, and that to truly heal, one must want to be healed oneself.
Daniel doesn’t realize that his own thoughts apply to himself—he pushes away every chance at love, be it from Samson, Leah, Malthace, or even Jesus. Malthace becomes a source of love and purpose beyond his hatred and thirst for vengeance. As much as he fights to stay firm on his self-destructive path, he is at the mercy of the love Malthace offers. In the battle between hatred and love, love’s slow but sure victory in Daniel’s life develops the text’s underlying theme that love is stronger than hatred. In an attempt at love and vulnerability, Daniel shares his burdens of Leah’s bad days and gives her the bow—a symbol of his deepest, most secret aspirations. He shares with Malthace what he never has with anyone.
Rosh’s wholesale looting serves as a critical turning point in the cause for Daniel’s boys. The boys are overjoyed at the opportunity to serve Rosh and the cause directly, and Joel throws himself into his role, but Daniel is deeply disappointed that Joel risked his life for something as lowly as a robbery. The same violent, plundering ways that once pleased Daniel now disgust him, and his struggle is now filled with the desire for nobler pursuits. Rosh’s refusal to free Joel from the Romans confirms Daniel’s burgeoning doubt in the outlaws on the mountain. The man who was once his hero is now no more than a calculating, selfish man. He sees with clarity the clash between the true meaning of their noble cause and Rosh’s immoral ways. Daniel is finally able to give word to his growing doubts in Rosh and start on a new path. In a climactic moment of truth, Daniel and his boys proclaim that they will stand for each other. They unanimously choose Daniel as their leader before setting off for Joel.
By Elizabeth George Speare