47 pages • 1 hour read
Mike LupicaA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Baseball symbolizes life because both produce countless possibilities. In Shel Silverstein’s poem, “Listen to Mustn’ts” (1993), the speaker tells the young reader, “Anything can happen, child, Anything can be” (Line 4). Mike Lupica’s presentation of baseball supports the claim of the famous children’s author. After Hutch commits the game-one error, Cody says, “What do you always tell me when I ask you why some game ended in some weird way?” Hutch answers, “I tell you that it’s baseball.” Cody concludes, “Baseball happened tonight” (183). In baseball, as in life, the unexpected occurs. Hutch can’t let his surprise error faze him, and people can’t let mistakes and unpredictable events stop them. Since “[a]nything can happen,” something amazing can follow something adverse. In game two, Hutch makes a Jeter-esque “flip” play. In baseball and life, the good and bad mix together; people can neither let the negative bring them down, nor let the positive inflate them. Thus, Hutch doesn’t heed the media attention about the error or the “flip” play: He stays level.
Hutch makes the symbolism explicit when he says, “In a lot of ways, it was like baseball, if you really thought about it. You took what they gave you” (51). Hutch refers to his dad coming to the game against the Yankees and seeing him hit the game-winning home run. At the time, Hutch doesn’t apply the lesson to life. By the end of the story, he accepts what his dad gives him. In life and baseball, adaptation is key. A player can’t subject baseball to their will and a person can’t control life. In each area, the individual must make the most of what is there.
Hutch idolizes the shortstop position, turning it into a symbol for the hero or the marquee player on the field. Hutch’s bedroom is a shrine to shortstops, featuring posters of Derek Jeter, Ozzie Smith, and Cal Ripken Jr. Though Hutch moves to second to accommodate Darryl, he still thinks of himself as a shortstop, leading the reader to believe he is playing shortstop in Chapter 1. Later, his craving to act like a shortstop causes a collision with Darryl, who reinforces the symbolism when he tells Hutch, “[E]verybody who plays ball knows who the captain of the infield is. And it’s never any second baseman” (90). The second baseman isn’t the hero but the sidekick to the shortstop. The second baseman isn’t “worth his weight in gold,” but the shortstop is a rare commodity (15). In contemporary baseball, the superstar shortstop can field, run, and hit for power and average. During the 2022-23 offseason, the top four shortstops on the free agent market made a combined $957 million (cited in Rymer, Zachary D. “MLB’s $957M Free-Agent SS Class Is Off to a Nightmare Start.” Bleacher Report, 26 May 2023).
Jeter is Hutch’s hero, and Hutch constantly consumes his “flip” play in the 2001 playoffs. Jeter made the play as a shortstop, strengthening the link between shortstops and heroes. In game two, Hutch makes a similar play as the second baseman, suggesting that different positions can produce heroic moments in baseball. Baseball is a team game, and the shortstop is only one of nine positions on the field.
The motif of belonging supports the three critical themes. To handle The Hopes and Pressures of Young Athletes, Hutch, Darryl, Cody, and the Cardinals must belong on “the big field.” Hutch and his team belong in the finals because they have “the same nerves, the same concentration, the same…fierceness to find a way to win the game” as pro baseball players (203). Hutch and his teammates develop the traits to excel in the spotlight.
To excel, the Cardinals apply the motif to The Necessity of Teamwork. The players belong together, so Hutch and Darryl can’t act like they are competing against one another. Hutch accepts that he belongs at second for now, and Darryl realizes that he is not a team unto himself. Hutch demonstrates he belongs at second when he makes the “flip” play. Darryl shows his belonging by listening to Hutch’s advice about the changeup and by giving Hutch advice about accepting his dad.
Hutch and his dad belong together. Though Hutch wishes his dad showed more interest in baseball, he learns to appreciate the moments he has with him, and he manages to accept his dispassionate attitude. The final hug represents the shared sense of belonging and the pivot from Son Versus Father to son and father.
By Mike Lupica