59 pages • 1 hour read
Kate ChopinA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Mrs. Pontellier cannot explain why at first she did not agree to accompany Robert and go for a swim with him, because she realizes that she did want to join him on the beach. She feels as if a light has been kindled in her, a light that directs her to “dreams, to thoughtfulness, to the shadowy anguish” (33) that had overwhelmed her the evening she was crying alone on the porch. Listening to the sounds of the sea, Edna begins to regard herself as an individual, and not merely as a part of the world around her.
Mrs. Pontellier is not used to discussing her feelings and private matters with others. Since she was a child, she had noticed a “dual life--the outward existence which conforms, the inward life which questions” (35). But as Edna grows closer to Adèle, she becomes less reticent. When one day the two women stroll to the beach, their differences in character are made visible in their garments: while Edna is dressed simply, Adèle wears an elegant white dress. When they reach the beach, Edna immediately loosens her clothes. Nearby they notice the lady in black, absorbed in her reading, and a young couple, who are kissing in an unoccupied tent.
Noting that Edna is being very quiet and thoughtful, Adèle wants to know what she is thinking. Edna is trying to retrace her thoughts. She replies that the sea makes her recall her Kentucky childhood, and strolling through a meadow “that seemed as big as the ocean to the very little girl” (41). Edna confesses that she went on the walk through the meadow instead of attending a session of Sunday prayers. She admits that she did not quite understand religion back then, but up until now, she has adhered to religious traditions, even if out of habit. Leaning closer to her companion, Edna confesses that “sometimes I feel this summer as if I were walking through the green meadow again; idly, aimlessly, unthinking and unguided” (43).
After hearing these words, Madame Ratignolle lays her hand over Edna’s hand and caresses it gently. This gesture confuses Edna; she is still not used to the openness with which Creoles express their affection. Edna thinks about other female friends she had when she was young. Edna admits that she never had close ties with her younger sister, Janet, while her older sister, Margaret, was always busy, since she was the one to take up all the house chores after their mother died when they were still children. Edna’s closest friend was a girl “of rather exceptional intellectual gifts” (44), whom she admired and with whom she sometimes had heated debates about politics and religion.
Not only female but also male figures had a strong impact on Edna throughout her adolescent years. She had many intense crushes on men but they never led anywhere. When Léonce appeared in her life, his devotion towards her surprised and pleased her. She found the prospect of marrying him even more appealing given that her Protestant father and sister did not like him because he was a Catholic. Edna’s intention to accept Léonce’s marriage proposal had another grounding as well. When Léonce was already courting her, she was hopelessly passionate about a well-known tragedian of the time, and so she hoped that marriage would end her foolish fantasies and anchor her in the real world. Therefore, regarding her marrying Léonce, she did not have romantic expectations or yearnings. Later on, when she saw that her affection towards Léonce is absent of passion and excitement, she was not disappointed, but rather satisfied.
Edna’s thoughts then turn to her sons. She acknowledges that she is “fond of her children in an uneven, impulsive way” (47). When they are away, except for the occasional minutes of longing, she does not miss them. Edna does not dare to admit, even to herself, that their absence is a kind of relief. When children are not around, Edna is liberated from responsibilities of motherhood “which she had blindly assumed and for which Fate had not fitted her” (48). Edna leans on her friend’s shoulder and, unexpectedly, shares some of these thoughts with Adèle. Her newfound honesty pleases her. Edna’s moment of openness with Adèle is interrupted by Robert, who comes to the beach together with the two women’s children. Edna goes off to join her children in the tent, forcing the young lovers under it to go someplace else, and Adèle, complaining of joint stiffness, asks Robert to accompany her as she walks back to the house.
After Edna’s confessions, Adèle is worried that Edna might take Robert’s flirting seriously and warns him to leave her alone. At first, he acts insulted and says that he hopes Edna does take him seriously, since he is annoyed with Creole women, who view his attention merely as a joke. Adèle reminds him of the risk he is taking: if he were to flirt with married women with serious intentions in mind, then he would ruin his reputation as a gentleman, and Creole husbands would not trust him to be around their wives anymore. Robert begins to explain to Adèle the appeal of a real affair, but suddenly changes his mind and instead begins to tell stories of a well-known seducer, Alcée Arobin. Adèle goes to her bedroom while Robert, after a brief search for Edna on the beach, stays with his mother at her cottage. The two talk about Robert’s brother, Victor, and the suitor who has been courting Robert’s mother since her husband died a long time ago.
A few weeks after Adèle has warned Robert about Edna, Madame Lebrun and her renters hold a Saturday-night celebration to entertain their weekend guests. The Farival twins open the celebration with their piano playing. They are girls of 14, and are always dressed in blue and white colors because their parents dedicated them to the Virgin Mary at their baptism. After they are done playing, several other children perform, and then Adèle plays the piano while the other guests dance. Edna, having danced with her husband, Robert, and Monsieur Ratignolle, goes out on the porch and sits there for some time alone, looking at the Gulf. Robert approaches her and asks whether she would like to hear Mademoiselle Reisz play. Mademoiselle Reisz is a bitter, middle-aged woman who quarrels with almost everyone, but she agrees to play for Edna when Robert asks her to do it. Before beginning her performance, Mademoiselle Reisz asks Edna what piece she would like to hear, but Edna does not dare to choose.
Edna greatly appreciates music. She liked to sit in the room when Adèle practiced her different pieces. Piano music stirred images of varying emotions in her mind: a naked man staring out at a fleeing bird in “hopeless resignation,” (65) a dancing woman, children at play. But now, as she listens to Mademoiselle Reisz play, Edna sees no pictures of emotions. Instead, she feels “the very passions themselves” overwhelming her to an extent of leaving her trembling and in tears. When Mademoiselle Reisz is done playing and is about to go home, she touches Edna’s shoulder and tells her that she is the only one worth playing for in this crowd. Nevertheless, the others also greatly enjoyed the performance and praise Mademoiselle Reisz’s skills. Robert suggests that all the guests go for a nighttime swim.
The moment of intimate honesty between Edna and Adèle on the beach makes a profound impact on both women. Adèle realizes that Edna, as she tells Robert, “is not one of us; she is not like us” (50). This realization does not impede Adèle’s fondness of Edna, but rather deepens it. Edna, remembering the infatuations she had before marriage, suddenly becomes aware of a huge contrast between those feelings and the feelings she has now towards her husband. Now that her true emotions have risen to the surface, she begins to see how much of herself she has been suppressing. Edna’s awakening unfolds even further when she voices these feelings to Adèle. Edna no longer wants to deny her sensual reactions to the world around her, and this change in her becomes especially visible in her emotional response to the music played by Mademoiselle Reisz a few weeks later.
Edna’s emotional response to Mademoiselle Reisz’s music is yet another manifestation of the awakening of her senses and passions. Although Edna has always been very responsive to music, her reactions to Adèle’s piano playing have been non-standard. This contrast brings to the fore the scope of her dawning self-discovery. The nature of mental images that Edna used to have while listening to Adèle play testifies to the narrowness of her earlier mindset. For instance, one of the pieces that Adèle used to play—“Solitude,” as Edna had named it—evoked in Edna’s mind the image of a naked man who had been left in isolation by a bird. Edna, then, associates deep emotions with a man, since it has been a social norm to disregard a woman’s capacity for such experiences. The figure of the bird symbolizes a woman, a phenomenon that can be observed multiple times in the text. However, Edna does not feel like she is the bird, but instead imagines that she is the abandoned man, which emphasizes her loneliness. The man’s nakedness symbolizes his vulnerability. In Edna’s vision, losing a partner equals becoming exposed to physical and emotional harm. It thus becomes clear that even though Edna seems to be different from everybody else, her vision reflects some stereotypes of Victorian-era society. Nevertheless, as she listens to Mademoiselle Reisz play, she reconnects with her deep emotions and passions, and begins to shed her outer layers of reserve and self-restraint.
The minor characters that surround Edna in these early chapters are also important. The lady in black and the young lovers are also at the beach, before and after Edna’s confessions to Adèle. They symbolically represent two stages in the life of a conventional Victorian woman. The lady in black symbolizes the tragedy that often goes hand in hand with love. She is also an embodiment of isolation that a woman inevitable faces when she is left without a husband. The young lovers represent a passionate romance that is supposed to foreshadow a happy marriage. However, much like the appearance of Edna’s children forces the lovers to leave the tent, family responsibilities often drive away emotional intimacy.
Although Edna finds sincere joy in music, women who perform it do so to be socially entertaining, and not to express themselves. Adèle, for example, admits that she continues to study music in order to brighten and beautify her home. Therefore, even art is not used as a means of self-expression, but merely as a means to entertain. The only exception from this unspoken rule is Mademoiselle Reisz, who seems to exist outside the conventional norms of Creole society. Edna, deeply disturbed by her performance, slowly breaks out of these societal conventions as well.
By Kate Chopin
American Literature
View Collection
Audio Study Guides
View Collection
Banned Books Week
View Collection
Historical Fiction
View Collection
Mothers
View Collection
Music
View Collection
National Suicide Prevention Month
View Collection
Naturalism
View Collection
Order & Chaos
View Collection
Summer Reading
View Collection