logo

58 pages 1 hour read

John Scalzi

Starter Villain

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2023

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 6-11Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 6 Summary

Charlie sits on the curb, gazing at the wreckage of his house amidst the flurry of fire and rescue teams. He calls Andy, who, while sympathetic, warns Charlie that he will likely be considered the prime suspect. Andy offers to contact the insurance company on Charlie's behalf and advises him to only talk to the police with legal representation present.

A neighbor offers Charlie a bowl of cat food, which he gratefully accepts. While feeding the cats and contemplating his housing options (potentially his father's 2003 Nissan Maxima), Charlie receives a sympathetic text from Morrison. After explaining his housing predicament, Charlie receives a call from Morrison, instructing him to follow his cats. Charlie looks at Hera uncertainly, who meows, and she and the kitten (now named Persephone) trot down the street. Charlie trails behind them to another small Cape Cod-style house just over a block away. The cats enter through a cat door, and after a moment of hesitation, Charlie rings the doorbell. He is buzzed in and discovers the house sparsely furnished but equipped with numerous cat stairs and cubbies. Hera leads him to a living room filled with cat trees, beds, and a desk with an unusual-looking monitor and keyboard. Hera jumps onto the desk, switches on the monitor, and types a message to Charlie. She apologizes for Charlie's loss and offers him a room in her house.

Chapter 7 Summary

Morrison finds Charlie outside, troubled. Morrison reveals that the cats are genetically modified and starts explaining Jake's business when Tobias, "The Stabber," appears. Morrison positions herself protectively in front of Charlie as tension rises. Tobias, attempting to ease the situation, mentions that he could have killed Charlie at the funeral home. Morrison and Tobias exchange insults, hinting at a past romance. Tobias hands Charlie an envelope, but Morrison insists Tobias open it, revealing an invitation. After a warning, Tobias leaves.

Inside, Hera informs Charlie he is now a target for Jake's rivals and reveals her dual role of surveillance and security. She details the attack on Charlie's house, suggesting the figure he saw in the window was likely CIA. Andy calls, offering a week's stay at a local motel covered by insurance. Andy also states that the FBI visited him and asked about Charlie. Considering his options, Charlie decides to stay in the hotel.

However, Morrison and Hera propose another plan: Charlie taking over Jake's businesses, including car garages and villainy, and attending the Lombardy Convocation, a villain conference detailed in Tobias's invitation. They have prepared escape documents in the name of Desmondo Jose Ruiz. Before anything else, Morrison suggests visiting the volcano lair.

Chapter 8 Summary

Situated on Saint Genevieve, a Caribbean island five miles north of Grenada, lies the "volcano lair." This volcanic island boasts a complex history, resulting in a vast subterranean complex. Currently owned by Allegheny Hospitality, Saint Genevieve provides a secure working environment for various research and development departments under Baldwin Holdings LLC, Jake's company.

Charlie is taken aback by the ease of his journey to the island using his fake passport. Upon arrival, Morrison gleefully reveals that her organization orchestrated an explosion in Charlie's insurance-funded hotel room, leading everyone, except Jake's associates, to believe Charlie is dead.

Once on Saint Genevieve, Morrison introduces Charlie to Joe Williams, the general manager of Allegheny Hospitality, responsible for overseeing all island operations. At Charlie's request, Williams accompanies him to meet the island's guard dolphins, who are considering going on strike.

Chapter 9 Summary

Charlie, Morrison, and Williams go to the Cetacean Division, where six dolphins quarrel with Astrud Livren, a female representative from the Cetacean Relations Department. The dolphins communicate through a microphone and display a general lack of respect for humans. Jake's refusal to recognize animal unions has left the dolphins furious about their labor conditions. Despite being crucial members of Saint Genevieve's Security and Intelligence teams, they struggle to strike due to their limited bargaining power. Although the dolphins technically have the freedom to leave, their genetic modifications hinder their ability to interact with wild dolphins. Charlie departs amidst a flurry of insults from the dolphins. He turns to Morrison for her opinion on the situation, but she chooses not to comment.

Chapter 10 Summary

Eve Yang, the head of Allegheny Hospitality's Human Resources department, delivers a PowerPoint presentation to Charlie on villainy's misrepresentation in media. This presentation is a standard part of the new hire process for executives and managers, emphasizing that villains are not inherently good or evil but rather "professional disrupters." Charlie remains cynical and sarcastic throughout, questioning the use of the term "villain" altogether. Eventually, Morrison suggests ending the presentation, sensing Charlie's lack of receptiveness.

Charlie remarks that villainy goes beyond world-threatening plots with giant lasers, only to be shown the Chauc 4, a disruptive laser commissioned by the US Department of Agriculture. While ostensibly designed for rainmaking, the Chauc 4 possesses additional capabilities to track, disrupt, destabilize, and even destroy satellites using energy from Saint Genevieve's volcano.

Instead of using this technology for blackmail, Baldwin Consultants, Jake's umbrella company for more nefarious ventures, offers a yearly subscription granting access to the technology. While none of the clients utilize the technology, they find comfort in the knowledge of its availability. Furthermore, certain clients, who are direct competitors, feel compelled to maintain the subscription as a precautionary measure, fearing that their rivals might exploit the technology against them.

Chapter 11 Summary

Morrison and Charlie return to the main complex, where Williams explains that they have apprehended a CIA agent, a not-uncommon occurrence. Williams and Morrison clarify that typically, captured operatives are interrogated and subsequently eliminated since the island lacks facilities for long-term detention.

Morrison escorts Charlie to interrogate the agent, Evan Jacobs. Jacobs provides a verification code, prompting Morrison to reveal that one of their services includes identity construction and destruction. Jacobs is there to fake his death and assume a new identity. Jacobs informs Charlie that he is no longer under investigation for the federal agent's death and that his alias, Desmondo Jose Ruiz, has been compromised. Furthermore, the CIA is uncertain about the identity of those behind the attempt on Charlie's life but suspects a connection to the Lombardy Convocation. Members of the convocation are apprehensive about Charlie's intentions to carry on his uncle's business strategies.

Shifting gears, Morrison presents Jacobs with options for his simulated demise, and Jacob defers, letting Charlie decide.

Chapters 6-11 Analysis

Charlie grapples with the interplay of Expectations, Perceptions, and Reality as he navigates the shadowy world left behind by his uncle. Scalzi employs humor to dissect The Nature of Villainy as Charlie's worldview undergoes a tumultuous transformation.

In a rapid succession of events, Charlie loses his home and his grasp on the world around him. Charlie's role at the funeral alters how others perceive him. No longer viewed as a mere failure, Charlie finds himself the subject of surveillance by a federal agency and the target of assassination attempts. However, this newfound attention is merely a matter of perception; Charlie's financial standing remains precarious, with little more than $40 to his name. Despite the illusion of inheriting Jake's fortune, Charlie's circumstances have not substantially improved; if anything, losing his home has left him worse off than before.

Hera's newfound sentience significantly affects Charlie's sense of Belonging and Identity. Initially, the narrative framed Charlie's discovery of Hera as a serendipitous encounter, suggesting a destined bond between them—a bond that only solidified when Charlie found Persephone in a similar manner. However, the revelation that Hera and Persephone were planted as spies inflicts a wound on Charlie's sense of self. Instead of Hera serving as a source of comfort and unconditional familial love, she has been clandestinely gathering information on Charlie, betraying his trust by relaying it to Jake and his cohorts. However, Charlie finds himself unable to sever his emotional attachment to Hera, compelled to fulfill her requests despite the betrayal. This internal conflict further exacerbates Charlie's sense of displacement and calls into question the authenticity of the relationships he holds dear.

Charlie's discovery of his uncle's villainous past forces him to confront and reconsider his preconceived notions of The Nature of Villainy, a journey peppered with Scalzi's characteristic humor. Embracing a humorous nod to The Fugitive, Charlie adopts an alternate identity that, despite its whimsicality, proves surprisingly effective in navigating the complexities of international travel. Jake's extravagant "volcano lair," complete with dolphin guards and a labyrinthine network of rooms and tunnels, fits the archetype of a villain's hideout. However, Charlie's expectations are repeatedly confounded as he delves deeper into the workings of Jake's corporation, Baldwin Consulting. Despite its ostensibly nefarious agenda, Baldwin Consulting operates much like any other corporation, with Charlie enduring mundane HR presentations in ordinary conference rooms. In one such presentation, the Human Resources representative, Eve Yang, attempts to redefine villainy, portraying it not as a moral judgment but merely as a job title. According to Yang’s presentation, villains’ actions are "neither inherently good nor bad in themselves—their ‘goodness’ or ‘badness’ [is] entirely dependent on the perspective of the observer" (85). As Charlie grapples with the realization that villainy is a matter of perspective, Scalzi injects the narrative with a dose of humor that both lightens the tone and underscores the complexity of Charlie's moral reckoning.

Despite Jake's staunch belief in his villainous endeavors, many of the technologies developed by his group prove to be beneficial, raising questions about The Nature of Villainy. Although the company adapts these technologies to suit their purposes, the cost-benefit analysis skews more toward neutrality than malevolence. While Baldwin Consulting possesses disruptive technology, like the laser, they have no intention of utilizing it for destructive purposes. As Morrison explains to Charlie, true villainy lies not in overt threats but in offering a service that remains unused. She explains, “A stupid villain threatens, Charlie. A smarter villain offers a service […] we make a lot of money offering a service no one uses” (90). Because clients know their competitors subscribe to the same service, no one can utilize the service, but neither can they unsubscribe from it. In other words, instead of Jake’s company blackmailing villains, “[t]hey blackmail each other. And pay [Baldwin Consulting] the fee" (92). Morrison's characterization of this business practice as "villainy" raises questions about the moral complexities inherent in such interactions, challenging conventional notions of innocence and guilt in a world where villainy is driven by the profit incentive.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text