17 pages • 34 minutes read
Naomi Shihab NyeA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Naomi Shihab Nye’s writing was already highly acclaimed by the publication of Red Suitcase, making her one of the leading voices within the literary community during the mid-1990s. The collection is largely about ordinary items—a grandmother’s scarf, an alarm clock, a father carrying his sleeping son on his shoulders—all of which are seen in a new light through Nye’s control over the English language. Her voice is warm, hopeful, and generous, turning the ordinary into something extraordinary.
One of Nye’s major literary influences is poet Carl Sandburg. Sandburg was known for using the language of the people, that is, everyday speech to construct his poems. He rejected the idea that poetry is highbrow and only for the exceedingly intelligent, such as in his short poem “Fog”:
The fog comes
on little cat feet.
It sits looking
over harbor and city
on silent haunches
and then moves on.
In “Fog,” Sandburg uses everyday speech and familiar terms like “cat” (Line 2), “harbor” (Line 4), and “city” (Line 4) to depict a mood of contemplation and movement via nature. Nye’s poetry exists within a similar space. Nye uses conversational language to construct her poems, such as in “Shoulders,” when she states: “A man crosses the street in rain, / stepping gently, looking two times north and south, / because his son is asleep on his shoulder” (Lines 1-3). The paired back lines here offer simple language, and yet the messages within Nye’s poems are extremely powerful and deeply moving, especially because they are relatable and intimate. “Shoulders” perfectly articulates the ethos of Nye’s writing as a whole, revealing to the masses that poetry is for everyone.
Naomi Shihab Nye takes American Individualism to task in her poem “Shoulders,” arguing that to create an equitable society, there needs to be a cultural shift to collectivism. Cultural individualism is defined by psychologist Harry C. Triandis as cultures that emphasize the needs and desires of singular people over the needs of the group, disregarding the interconnectedness of people that live in the same country, and therefore, within the same culture (Triandis, Harry C. “Collectivism and Individualism as Cultural Syndromes.” Sage Publications. 1993). Nye provides this cultural critique subtly within the lines of “Shoulders,” comparing the kindness of the father to the outright apathy of the people driving past him and his sleeping son in their cars.
People who live in individualist cultures tend to believe that independence and competition are pillars of daily life, with many becoming egotistical and self-serving as a result. Nye uses the selfless father as an example, offering readers an alternative to the cultural values they have grown up with by showing someone willing to put someone else before their own needs. Collectivism, or the practice of giving a group priority over the individual, is inherently empathetic, cementing Nye’s argument that “we’re not going to be able / to live in this world” (Lines 13-14) if we are not willing to treat our neighbor as we would treat ourselves and those we hold most dear. With this cultural context in mind, Nye’s intended audience is decidedly the American public, urging them to shift their thinking so the next generation has a brighter future in which to grow up.
By Naomi Shihab Nye