logo

46 pages 1 hour read

Lisa See

Shanghai Girls

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2009

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 3, Chapters 16-20Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 3: “Destiny”

Part 3, Chapter 16 Summary: “Haolaiwu”

By September 1941, Joy is over three years old and a popular extra in the movies where May is able to cast her. One day, Pearl visits the movie set and gets a role as an extra. She plays a Chinese peasant fleeing from the Japanese with Joy in her arms. Flashing back to her real encounter with the enemy, Pearl’s screams are so convincing that the director offers to pay her for a speaking part. Jealous, May demands the part for herself. The sisters get into a fight over their petty rivalries and jealousies, but Pearl yields and lets May play the role.

Part 3, Chapter 17 Summary: “Snapshots”

In December of that year, Japan attacks Pearl Harbor, and America is now at war. Sam and Vern try to enlist. Vern’s mental disabilities disqualify him, and Sam is classified as 4F because of his flat feet. During the next 15 months, the family adjusts to life during wartime, but this is nothing like the misery of Shanghai during the Japanese invasion. In the café one day, Pearl meets an old acquaintance. Mr. Howell is the father of her school friend Betsy. The family is American, and Howell works for the State Department. Pearl learns that Betsy never left Shanghai and is now in a Japanese detention camp.

Sometime later, May inherits the casting business from her employer and runs a thriving concern to supply the film industry with Chinese bit players. May, herself, continues to be in demand as an actress though she will never become famous like Anna May Wong. By now, Joy is old enough to attend school, but she is immediately rejected by the white school where her parents try to send her. Around the same time, the Chinese Exclusion Act is repealed by President Roosevelt, but local prejudice against Asians still continues.

Part 3, Chapter 18 Summary: “Ten Thousand Happinesses”

The family has begun to prosper in a modest way when Pearl realizes she is pregnant. The entire family is excited that this time she might have a son. Pearl consults with a white doctor who says it is unlikely she will carry the baby to term because of her age and internal scarring. Nevertheless, everyone remains hopeful.

At this point, Sam proposes buying a house for his growing family. He and Pearl have saved enough to make this possible, but buying anything outside of Chinatown is difficult since prejudice remains. By the time Pearl is six months pregnant, she receives a letter from Betsy, who is still in China. With the war over, she is released from the internment camp and intends to rejoin her family in Washington, DC.

Part 3, Chapter 19 Summary: “The Air of This World”

In the summer of 1949, Pearl is nearly ready to deliver her baby. When her water breaks, Pearl is taken to an American hospital by May and Vern. Sadly, her baby is a stillborn son. Pearl must undergo a hysterectomy, so there is no remaining chance of having another baby. While recovering in the hospital, she learns that Sam consulted with the doctors about Vern’s deteriorating physical condition. They report that he has tuberculosis of the bone, and his spine is disintegrating. The family refuses to put him in a hospital, so they care for him at home.

By August of that year, tragedy strikes again when China City suffers another major fire. As in the earlier fire, most of Old Man Louie’s enterprises are affected. The family decides to relocate their businesses to New Chinatown instead. In October, Pearl and Sam open Pearl’s Coffee Shop, and it does quite well with Americans who have developed a taste for Chinese cuisine. By this time, the Communists have taken over China, and North Korea has invaded the South. As a result, China is now regarded as an enemy, and Chinese Americans are viewed with suspicion. Betsy comes west to visit Pearl and declares that the old Shanghai is gone, never to return.

Part 3, Chapter 20 Summary: “Fear”

By November 1950, American paranoia about Communism intensifies. Business in the new coffee shop has slowed as white customers avoid the Chinese district. Around Christmas, the family receives an eviction notice, so it’s time to find their own house. Pearl locates a property in Chinatown and feels that everything will finally work out. Unfortunately, Yen-yen dies unexpectedly, and Old Man Louie is devastated.

The family has little time to mourn since they must move into their new house. Pearl now has the difficult job of caring for Vern as he deteriorates further. Even though she isn’t a Christian, Pearl starts praying to the Christian god. She does this “to bring peace of mind, to make sense of all the bad things in my life, and to believe that maybe all this suffering will be rewarded in Heaven” (248).

Part 3, Chapters 16-20 Analysis

As the years proceed, the differences between Pearl and May grow more obvious. The Bond of Sisterhood is strained again because of disputes about Joy. May is perceived as the fun auntie who can bring Joy to movie sets. In contrast, Pearl is the strict parent trying to raise a dutiful Chinese daughter. The rivalry between the sisters hits a new peak in this segment when they fight over a minor movie role. The trivial reason for the dispute causes them to air a lifetime of grievances against one another. Pearl notes the cyclical nature of this dynamic when she says, “That’s what sisters do: we argue, we point out each other’s frailties, mistakes, and bad judgment, we flash the insecurities we’ve had since childhood, and then we come back together. Until the next time” (202).

Aside from a brief examination of the dynamics of sisterhood, this set of chapters is replete with tragedies. Again, the theme of being Trapped by Circumstance is foregrounded. The family is afflicted by another fire in Chinatown that briefly wipes out Old Man Louie’s enterprises. Over the years, Pearl has realized that her off-putting father-in-law is just as trapped as she is. She notes this fact after taking a family photo: “He has almost nothing here in Los Angeles: he’s a third-class citizen, he faces the same discrimination we all do, and he will never break out of Chinatown” (205).

If this crisis weren’t enough of a test, the family soon experiences Pearl’s miscarriage, Vern’s degenerating spine, and the death of Yen-yen. As Pearl watches the men in her family succumb to pressure while she is forced to carry on, she bitterly notes the contrast between males, who are overvalued for their strength, while female endurance is devalued:

The men in my life […] faced, to one degree or another, those great male battles, but their hearts—so fragile—wilted, buckled, crippled, corrupted, broke, or shattered when confronted with the losses women face every day (228).

At the same time that the family deals with its domestic crises, the larger world once more steps in to add another layer of entrapment. Initially, the Chinese are viewed as allies against the Japanese during World War II. Almost overnight, this perception changes when Communists take power in post-war China. The red scare—paranoia about the influence and intentions of foreign Communist nations—makes American politicians particularly concerned about Chinese immigrants living in their midst.

Pearl has always recognized the American need to confine her people within the enclosure of Chinatown. Now, she sees these efforts at segregation intensify. Her daughter is denied the chance to go to a white school where she might receive a better education. Likewise, Pearl cannot purchase a house in a nicer white neighborhood. Even more worrisome is the prospect of being investigated by the government. Pearl’s paranoia is mirrored in the faces of her neighbors. The local butcher says, “And you don’t even have to say anything bad. All you have to be is a Chinese living in this pit of a country!” (241). Pearl finds herself trapped by world events yet again.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text