logo

46 pages 1 hour read

Lisa See

Shanghai Girls

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2009

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 1, Chapters 5-10Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 1: “Fate”

Part 1, Chapter 5 Summary: “Moon Sisters”

Content Warning: Chapter 6 depicts rape and sexual violence.

Pearl goes to the steamship office to try to exchange their tickets with no success. The clerk tells her it is becoming impossible to get out of the city. Meanwhile, millions of refugees from the countryside are fleeing to Shanghai to escape the advancing Japanese army. Back at home, Pearl learns that Mr. Chin hasn’t come back. May, Pearl, and Mrs. Chin wait up until past midnight, but he never arrives. Mrs. Chin decides that something has happened to him, so the women of the family must save themselves.

She reveals a hidden stash of money to tide them over. Then, she packs her jewelry and the marriage papers of May and Pearl. They hire a wheelbarrow pusher to take them to the Grand Canal, where they can get a boat bound for Hong Kong. Mrs. Chin has bound feet, which have become infected, so she must sit in the wheelbarrow while the others walk. For two nights, they travel by foot and lodge with impoverished farm families.

Part 1, Chapter 6 Summary: “Soaring Through the Night Sky”

On the third day, they find signs of destruction by the Japanese army. Corpses of murdered civilians and raped women are lying in the villages they pass. That night, they shelter in an abandoned house. After the Chins settle down to sleep, they hear the sound of men approaching. Their wheelbarrow pusher is killed outside. Mrs. Chin hides the girls in a back bedroom and goes out to act as a decoy. She is soon gang raped by a group of Japanese soldiers. During this ordeal, the soldiers unwrap her malformed feet and stomp on the bones to straighten them out, causing Mrs. Chin unendurable agony.

Pearl can’t stand the sound of her mother’s screams and steps out of the bedroom to help. When the soldiers see her, they gang-rape her repeatedly until an officer arrives and commands the men to leave. Shortly after they depart, Pearl tries to revive her mother. Mrs. Chin tells her eldest daughter to take care of May and dies shortly afterward from her injuries. At this point, Pearl loses consciousness.

Part 1, Chapter 7 Summary: “Eating Wind and Tasting Waves”

Pearl doesn’t awaken until days later in a hospital. When she revives, she learns that May used some of their money to get them to Hangchow. Pearl was feverish and on the point of death. After six weeks and repeated surgeries to repair her ravaged body, she starts to recover.

Shortly after this point, the sisters board a ship that will take them from Hangchow to Hong Kong. During their voyage, the vessel is attacked by pirates. However, Pearl and May had the foresight to hide their remaining money, so the pirates don’t find it. Once in Hong Kong, they board a ship bound for San Francisco. During their voyage, they finally get word of the turmoil in Shanghai and are glad to have escaped in time.

Part 1, Chapter 8 Summary: “Shadows on the Wall”

The night before they make port, Pearl takes out a coaching book that her husband Sam gave her. It contains all the facts about his family that Pearl will need to answer when immigration officials question her. May has a book too, but she fails to study it carefully.

Once they arrive, the Chinese passengers are herded like cattle and taken to Angel Island, the Ellis Island of the West for processing immigrants. When May and Pearl are questioned, their stories don’t tally completely. They are called back for questioning on multiple occasions until weeks turn into months. After an eight-hour interrogation, Pearl returns to find May in the bunkhouse and complains about her sister’s inability to back her story. May abruptly announces that she is pregnant.

Part 1, Chapter 9 Summary: “Isle of the Immortals”

May explains that she got pregnant before the arranged wedding took place. The father is someone Pearl doesn’t know. May wants to make sure the baby is born on the island, so she can’t be sent back to China. Further, she must pass the baby off as belonging to Pearl. That way, Old Man Louie will accept the baby as his grandchild because he knows that Pearl and Sam consummated their marriage, but May didn’t. The sisters start to dress in baggy peasant clothing so that it will appear Pearl is the one who is pregnant. Their detention continues for four months.

Part 1, Chapter 10 Summary: “Sisters in Blood”

In the middle of the night, Pearl finds May in labor in the women’s bathroom. The two sisters manage to deliver the baby without attracting any notice. It’s a girl, and they decide to call her Joy. The other women in the camp don’t suspect that May is actually the mother. Pearl says she will bottle feed the baby as modern women do, so no one notices that she isn’t lactating either.

After the birth, the sisters send a telegram to their spouses. “The message is short and to the point: MAY AND PEARL ARRIVED ANGEL ISLAND. SEND TRAVEL FUNDS. BABY BORN. PREPARE ONE-MONTH BIRTHDAY” (123). During the next round of interrogation, Pearl shows up with a baby. Since Joy was born in America, this makes her a citizen. This is such a bureaucratic nightmare that the officials immediately decide to allow the sisters into the country. Pearl and May collect their belongings and board a ferry to take them to San Francisco.

Part 1, Chapters 5-10 Analysis

In the book’s second segment, the theme of being Trapped by Circumstance intensifies. Not only are Pearl and May manipulated in the transaction among Baba Chin, Old Man Louie, and the Green Gang, but the entire city of Shanghai is under siege by the Japanese. Fate takes another difficult turn when Mr. Chin disappears completely, leaving the women in his family to fend for themselves. To this point, Pearl, May, and Mrs. Chin have maintained their upper-class status, but sheltering with peasants gives them a different perspective. Pearl says:

We don’t know what it means to get by on almost nothing. […] But the family that lives here and the woman who took us in last night do. When you don’t have much, having less isn’t so bad (72).

Disasters increase in this segment when Pearl and Mrs. Chin are assaulted by Japanese soldiers and left for dead. Shortly before she dies, Mrs. Chin pleads with Pearl to take care of May by referring to the ever-present symbolism of astrology. She tells her daughter:

You’re a Dragon, and of all the signs only a Dragon can tame the fates. Only a Dragon can wear the horns of destiny, duty, and power. Your sister is merely a Sheep. You have always been a better mother to her than I have (76).

Throughout the novel, the zodiac symbolism is associated with the theme of being Trapped by Circumstance. Ironically, Mrs. Chin says that Pearl has the power to transcend fate because of her zodiac sign, but after hearing these words, she collapses. It is May, the Sheep, who ultimately finds a way to save her.

Pearl and May obediently board a ship for America and go to meet the destiny that has been set for them by others. When they arrive on Angel Island for immigration processing, they encounter yet another layer of entrapment. Neither girl knows that the American government desires to limit the influx of Asian immigrants to its shores. Pearl and May become the victims of this political mandate: “Not only can we not become naturalized citizens, but the government passed a law in 1882 barring the immigration of all Chinese” (109).

Pearl and May had assumed that America would welcome them with open arms. Their only recourse is to prove that they are the legal wives of men who belong to the merchant class. Having their lives arranged by the males in their families, being terrorized by Japanese invaders, and being obstructed by the whims of the American government lead Pearl and May to conclude that they can only turn to each other for support. The Bond of Sisterhood is strengthened in this segment because of the entrapment they must face together. This proves doubly true when May confesses her pregnancy, and the sisters manage to pass off Joy as Pearl’s baby. Pearl says, “All May and I have left is each other. After everything we’ve been through, our tie is so strong that not even a sharp knife could sever it” (85).

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text