logo

37 pages 1 hour read

Barbara Demick

Nothing to Envy

Nonfiction | Book | Adult | Published in 2009

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapter 19-EpilogueChapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 19 Summary: “Strangers in the Homeland”

This chapter tells the stories of most main characters’ defection and integration. Dr. Kim becomes a nanny to a South Korean professor living in China. Invited back to South Korea by the professor, she reveals her true identity. Upon arriving, she loses her resettlement money in a scam, and discovers her medical training will not suffice in her new home. She re-enters medical school at forty years old. Kim Hyuck immigrates at age nineteen with the help of missionaries. He takes a harsh route through Mongolia, is captured by police, and is then released to South Korea. There, he struggles to understand customs and find consistent work. At twenty-six,he re-enrolls in college, and discovers that his status as a defector has some cache. 

Chapter 20 Summary: “Reunion”

This chapter concludes Mi-ran and Jun-sang’s romance. As compared to other North Koreans, Mi-ran’s integration is easy because of the South Korean heritage that had given her family such a low social standing in her childhood. Jun-sang, by contrast, has difficulty making his way to South Korea, or adjusting once he arrives. After Mi-ran’s departure, he moves back to Chongjin to avoid government surveillance, and spends years saving money. After crossing the border into China, he works at a brick factory, and contemplates returning to North Korea—until he discovers the Internet. Online, he finds help, and, like Hyuck, goes through Mongolia. Once he arrives in South Korea, he learns that Mi-ran is married, and hesitates to contact her. A year after his arrival, he runs into her brother, and then contacts her. Upon reuniting, Mi-ran asks him, “‘if you were going to come to South Korea, why didn’t you come sooner?’” (282). Now married and a mother, it is too late for their romance to thrive. 

Epilogue Summary: “Waiting”

Demick concludes by turning to the situation of North Korea at the time of the book’s publication in 2010. She notes that, despite years of predictions that the regime would fall, it shows no sign of doing so. After a disastrous attempt to confiscate all currency circulating and crack down on markets, the government was forced to apologize to its people, but the regime remained. Foreign journalists including Demick continued to be treated to displays of wealth and power—lavish buffets, a city lit up with electricity—but after their departure, they learned that these were indeed for their benefit only. She concludes by noting that, whenever travelling to North Korea, she and others observe citizens sitting “for hours on their haunches…[t]hey stare straight ahead as though they are waiting…just waiting for something to change” (296). It is implied that they are waiting for the fall of the regime.

Chapter 19-Epilogue Analysis

Concluding the defection narratives of the book’s main characters, these chapters continue to stress the difficulty of adjusting to life in South Korea. The conclusion to Mi-ran and Jun-sang’s romance in particular demonstrates the huge break between a defector’s two lives. The intimacy and passion shared by the two all but dissolves when they move out of the disconnected, repressive environment of North Korea to the hyper-connected, permissive culture of South Korea. The failure and end of their romance marks a turning point in both their lives, stressing the mixed fruits of relocation.

These chapters also, however, stress that as difficult as acculturation may be for those who resettle, life remains precarious in North Korea. The epilogue in particular notes that the glimmer of hope visible in the black markets and end of the famine has faded. As of 2010, rates of starvation and death had escalated. However, it is also implied that the tide of change is irreversible, as cell phones and Western products increasingly keep defectors and residents in touch.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text