46 pages • 1 hour read
Hans FalladaA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Johannes Pinneberg is the novel’s protagonist. He is not particularly attractive, intelligent, rich, poor, or ambitious. Instead, his story functions as a way in which to chart the fate of an unremarkable man during a remarkable period in history. The collapse of the Weimar Republic, the hyperinflation of the German mark, and The Rise of the Nazi Party are historic events that contrast with the relatively mundane existence of a young man who gets his lover pregnant and tries to make a life with her in difficult circumstances. Johannes may lack ambitions but, once he learns that Emma is pregnant, he begins to develop a view toward his future. He seeks to adhere to traditional gender roles as the male provider and the head of the household, even though Economic Collapse and Societal Breakdown make his efforts almost impossible. His struggles to conform to social expectations illustrate the extent to which society is collapsing.
Johannes always sells his labor to his bourgeois bosses, but he believes his status as an office worker gives him some elevation above blue-collar laborers. Despite how important this status is to Johannes, he always feels like an imposter. He does not gain his bookkeeping job through study and hard work. Instead, he gets the job by befriending a client who hires him to spite a Jewish tailor. When he tries to find another bookkeeping job, his lack of training and experience makes this impossible. Johannes may insist that he is a genuine white-collar worker, but he knows this status is precarious. Johannes’s insecurity can be ascribed to many others in his position, which accounts for the competition and rivalry among the white-collar workers.
Johannes’s descent into poverty makes him question his identity. When he loses his job, he stays at home and watches their son while Emma earns money. During his visit to Berlin, his identity crisis comes to a head. After 14 months without work, he no longer believes that he is entitled to wear the uniform of the white-collar worker, so he removes his collar, placing it alongside his tie in his pocket. As soon as he does so, he is chased through the streets by a police officer, a brutal reminder of his loss of status. When Johannes returns to Emma, she provides him with an alternative identity: He can be her lover, her partner, and Markel’s father. Rather than defining himself by social expectations, she suggests that he define himself in relation to his family. The novel ends before Johannes can fully explore this identity, but the revelation that there is another way to conceive of the self gives him immense comfort.
As Germany descends into right-wing fascism, Emma is raised in a distinctly left-wing, pro-labor household. Her father and brother speak often and openly about political matters; their views on the importance of labor solidarity are echoed by Emma’s comments later in the novel as she encourages Johannes to adopt workplace solidarity even though she has never had a real job of her own. Whereas Johannes never really engages with politics out of anything more than an emotional reaction to whatever has happened to him most recently, Emma is sincere in her support for the Communist Party.
Emma leaves her family once she learns that she is pregnant. She marries Johannes in a small and hastily organized ceremony, then begins to think about her future, as well as the future that she wants for her child. She is not shy about predictions: She immediately assumes that her baby will be a boy and she chooses the name Markel just a few months into the pregnancy. Markel dominates Emma’s thoughts, and every financial and professional decision the couple makes is conditioned on what Emma wants for her baby’s future. She forbids alcohol and cigarettes in the house, for example, and demands that they move out of their first home because she does not want Markel to grow up in such a place. Markel becomes the cornerstone of Emma’s identity. Not only does she begin to conceive of herself as a mother more than anything else, but Markel provides her with an opportunity to live vicariously. Through her son, she can experience the kind of childhood that she never experienced for herself. Markel becomes a vehicle for Emma’s ambitions; he is a way for her to achieve whatever she was too poor, too feminine, or too young to achieve.
Emma struggles with her newfound role as Johannes’s wife. She does not know how to cook, keep house, or manage the household budget. However, she has a fundamental conception of how a wife should act, so she strives to play this role to please her husband. Eventually, however, this attempt to play a role is blown apart by Economic Collapse and Societal Breakdown. When Johannes loses his job, Emma becomes the breadwinner. She goes out to work while he stays home, inverting their previous, more traditional roles of husband and wife. Emma works long hours for very little pay but she does so selflessly, sacrificing herself to support the family during their desperate poverty. She also provides Johannes with emotional support. When he loses his sense of identity, she reminds him of the love of his family and encourages him to adopt this as his new identity. This emotional maturity illustrates the extent to which Emma grows as a character.
Holger Jachmann is a charming criminal. He enters the story through his association with Mia Pinneberg, Johannes’s mother. Mia introduces him to the young couple as her “lover at present” (110). While Johannes has no real relationship with his father, he develops a bond of sorts with Jachmann, who takes pity on him and Emma. Jachmann is capable of genuine empathy, which motivates him to give money and advice to Johannes. He not only secures Johannes a job at the department store but he also makes regular monetary gifts to the young couple. When they attempt to sneak out of Mia’s house, Jachmann catches them. Rather than alert Mia, he helps them to exit in secret. Though he is devoted to Mia, he acknowledges that neither he nor Mia are good people. Unlike Johannes and Emma, Jachmann does not seek to conform to social expectations. He runs card tricks and other schemes; he breaks the law and is richly rewarded for doing so. The only time he is actually punished is when he is sent to prison for 12 months, though he returns to his old illegal practices as soon as he is released. A year spent in prison is evidently worth the riches gained from breaking the law.
Jachmann’s character provides an important element of the novel’s social critique, challenging society’s assumption that what is moral is necessarily lawful. Contrary to his assessment of himself, Jachmann is moral in many ways, helping those most in need and demonstrating sincere empathy in a time of economic turmoil. However, the wealth he uses to help others is gained through illegal means. Jachmann’s desire to help Johannes and Emma can be interpreted as a form of penance, in which he recognizes their desire to live according to the rules and provides them with compensation as a way of offsetting his infractions. That he feels the need to do so suggests that he is disillusioned with society’s ability to deal with men like him.
Joachim Heilbutt works alongside Johannes in Mandel’s department store. Whereas the other workers struggle to hit their sales targets, Heilbutt is a naturally gifted salesperson. His natural talent and confidence lead Johannes to assume that he secretly belongs to a higher social class, as a desperately poor person could not maintain such a confident demeanor. Johannes’s suspicions prove correct; Heilbutt is indeed more privileged than other characters. He inherits property from family members and has enough capital to start a business amid Economic Collapse and Societal Breakdown. In spite of their differences, Heilbutt has a sincere desire to help Johannes, offering to loan him money, covering for his scandalous mother, and allowing Johannes and Emma to live rent-free in the summer house he inherits. Heilbutt’s charity teaches Johannes a lesson about Class Identity, Rivalry, and Solidarity. He is of a different class than Johannes, yet he shows him far more support than the other white-collar workers in the store do. Through Heilbutt’s goodness, Johannes begins to realize that white-collar solidarity is a sham.
Heilbutt is not without his secrets, however. He is a nudist, someone who is wholly committed to living a life without clothes, but he recognizes that he will be condemned by society if his secret becomes known. Heilbutt only reveals his nudist beliefs to Johannes when Johannes visits unexpectedly. He is later forced to reveal his beliefs in the workplace when a magazine article reprints a nude photograph of him without his consent. Heilbutt wins a labor tribunal and is compensated for his unlawful sacking, but the reputational damage has been done. His nudist views are considered scandalous.
Heilbutt has the final laugh, however. As the store continues to struggle with sales, Heilbutt embraces his identity as a nudist. He becomes a dealer in nude photographs, leaning into his passion and publicly acknowledging his beliefs. Heilbutt’s success shows that nudity and nudism are not as niche as polite society would like to believe. He sells photographs and grows his business precisely because many people are interested in such images. Heilbutt achieves success by embracing his true self, but he is only able to do so because he has the means. Those of a lower status, like Johannes, cannot afford to entertain such ambitions.