86 pages • 2 hours read
Andrea ElliottA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
The ACS representatives reach Dasani at Hershey during Columbus Day weekend, when most people are gone. She is watching the movie Unbroken, a biopic about a WWII pilot detained by the Japanese. Against Chanel’s request, they inform her of the situation. Later, Dasani will speak with her mother through the home phone. Chanel is furious that ACS informed Dasani of this situation without her consent, and believes “[t]his is how they break the bond” (473). Dasani’s behavior consequently deteriorates, and she slips down the Hershey scale just as school begins. Her houseparents try to help her by pointing out that they have had a lot of painful experiences as well.
Dasani’s siblings have been placed in foster homes with various families throughout the city. The children seem to be on their best behavior, except for Papa, who acts out by digging a hole in his faster parents’ yard, filling it with water, and “slinging mud at a neighbor’s house” (475). Chanel contacts the ACS supervisor who went to visit Dasani and expresses her frustration at the decision, informing them that it has affected her performance and her behavior.
Dasani manages to go without outbursts for some time, but she has stopped tracking her goals. She works to earn back her right to cheer and participates in a cheer at a football game against a local team. She completes a difficult stunt and feels ecstatic at her success.
Chanel and Supreme, preparing to attend a visitation with their children, meet Linda Lowe, the family’s new Foundling supervisor. Chanel initially dismisses her as a “white devil” (484) because of the way she comports herself, but she eventually grows to respect her willingness to bend rules and recognize that Chanel has lived a difficult life. In fact, Linda has undergone her own struggles. Though her father was a Wall Street stock broker, he was also abusive and had an addiction to alcohol. Linda feels that her childhood experiences give her a good perspective on what the families she works with are going through.
At the visit, Chanel fusses over the children while Supreme hands out snacks and leaves to get them food. Chanel and Supreme sign paperwork allowing the children to receive medical and psychiatric care while in foster care even though they have reservations about vaccines. Linda believes Supreme has good intentions and cares for his children, and that an aid would be more effective and less expensive while sparing their family the trauma of separation. The family qualifies for a program that provides this kind of service, but ACS never informed them of it.
Chanel meets with Attorney Yost, who indicates simply that “Chanel must do whatever ACS asks” (490), and she has 15 months to do so, or parental rights may be terminated. This policy was initiated under Clinton’s Welfare law in 1997. Chanel tries to prompt the attorney to sue ACS, but he believes that it would be pointless as they only need to provide a “preponderance of evidence” to do as they have done (491).
Dasani has not talked to her mother in some time. In her new favorite class, law, many of the students ask “questions tinged with personal worry” (494). Avianna and Nana are living in an immaculate foster home with a swimming pool. Lee-Lee is separated from this family again. She goes to live with Auntie Joan with Maya and Hada.
Dasani comes home for Thanksgiving, and the family reunites at a supervised visit with some of the foster parents present, as well as the Foundling caseworker Linda. Chanel tries to be diplomatic with the foster parents, whereas Dasani is generally cold. After, Dasani says that she doesn’t want to come back again.
Khaliq participates in the “Knockout Game,” in which he sneaks up behind an unsuspecting person and tries to knock them out. Khaliq is also getting into trouble with his foster parents. They find a joint in his possession, which puts him at risk of being separated from Papa. Dasani feels responsible for the trouble her family members are having, feeling that she was selfish to choose Hershey. Khaliq is arrested for the first time in his life. He recognizes that he will now have trouble pursuing his dreams in the Navy, so he tries to make other plans to be successful. Two tablets go missing at his foster home, and Khaliq is accused of stealing and relocated to another foster home.
Avianna holds a bake sale, giving the proceeds to an animal shelter. Her act of generosity is reported in the same newspapers that also reported on Khaliq’s criminal behavior, though the papers do not connect the two as siblings. It is around Christmas, and everyone in the family is struggling. Dasani is at Hershey, mostly by herself, and is contacted by Avianna and Nana—the former seems to be drinking alcohol. At Hershey, Dasani’s new white roommate accuses Dasani of stealing, which results in an altercation. In January, she gets into a fight with another girl, which results in probation. At her house in Hershey, she waves a knife around at her housemates, which results in her being sent to a mental health facility overnight for evaluation. She is placed on “behavioral restitution” at Hershey (511).
The siblings live at four different addresses. Nobody seems to be keeping track of Khaliq, who often shows up broke and hungry at Supreme and Chanel’s home. Supreme and Chanel have fallen into drug use again and are depressed. Chanel runs into Miss Hester, who has been in the system of houselessness herself for a few years, saving up after being evicted so she can get a new place. She tries to be warm toward Chanel, but she is dismayed by her appearance.
A big snowstorm hits both New York City and Hershey. Ignoring her knee pain and lack of proper footwear, Chanel finds work shoveling the snow. Dasani is becoming more vulnerable and more willing to apologize and express gratitude. In Avianna and Nana’s foster care home, Mr. Byrd is abusive toward his wife, their son was recently arrested for cocaine possession, and a child recently drowned in Mrs. Byrd’s pool. She continues to run a daycare without a license. One evening Mr. Byrd and his son become violent toward Avianna and Nana until Mrs. Byrd intervenes before he strikes Avianna. This results in a call to 911, and the children are eventually moved to a different foster home that is very crowded. Avianna believes the new foster mother “just wants the money” (518).
Nana and Avianna talk with Dasani on the phone. They don’t discuss the situation with the Byrds, though they do indicate they are in a new foster home. Nana is being bullied at home, and she and Avianna accuse Dasani of turning white. She talks to her mother about coming home, but Chanel says that if she comes back to New York, she will enter the foster system. Her Black mentors at Hershey have tried to convince her that she doesn’t need to “‘be white’ to succeed” (519), but she is not so sure. She dreams of opening a music production business with her siblings.
In March, Dasani is temporarily being removed from the Akers house after another fight. She blames the school for not giving her enough support. The assistant principal, Tara, tries to convince her that she is better off walking away from an argument, but Dasani follows her mother’s advice when it comes to protecting her reputation. At the Akers’ house, she often seems sad and withdrawn. She worries about Khaliq. She is closer to Kali, who shares her generalized anger.
Khaliq has become more violent. He has assaulted strangers and gotten into fights at school. His foster mother is surprised by his behavior, as he is always helpful at home. He ends up in a juvenile detention facility, and Chanel tells his court-appointed lawyer to emphasize that his behavior stems from his family having been broken up by the system. Supreme tells Khaliq he should know better and that he must learn to walk away. In a few days, Supreme will enter another rehab program to get clean. The judge imposes a strict curfew but allows Khaliq to return to foster care.
At Hershey, Dasani signs an agreement to improve her behavior. Tara asks Chanel to talk to Dasani about this plan, hoping that her mother will be able to get through to her. Chanel is in a new methadone program and has lost weight, which always signals to Dasani that she isn’t doing well. She encourages Dasani to take advantage of her opportunity so she doesn’t end up like her mother.
In Part 6, the various conflicts that have been simmering throughout the narrative begin to boil over into crisis. ACS interventions continue to increase, to the extent that caseworkers visit Dasani in Hershey and, against her mother’s wishes, inform her of the situation at home.
Though living in very different circumstances, Khaliq and Dasani’s stories parallel. Khaliq becomes increasingly violent and is arrested for the first time. Even he doesn’t seem to understand his behavior, and he falls into a cycle of wanting to do better but not knowing how. He continues to obsessively clean and do chores, trying to exert control over an increasingly uncontrollable situation.
Dasani’s behavior deteriorates—a development that can be traced to ACS’s decision to inform her of the situation at home. She gets into fights, resulting in increasingly severe disciplinary measures from Hershey. The mentors around her continue to try to give her tools to make better choices, but without making significant progress. Like Khaliq, she seems to be trapped in a pattern of behavioral disruptions arising from her powerlessness to help her family.
Khaliq and Dasani’s behavioral problems speak to The Conflict Between Systemic Bias and Individual Responsibility. Systems hold both to account for their choices: Khaliq is repeatedly arrested, while Dasani edges closer to expulsion from Hershey. At the same time, it’s clear that both siblings’ disruptive behaviors are rooted in the challenges Elliott listed in the very first chapter: “hunger, violence, racism, homelessness, parental drug addiction, pollution, segregated schools”—circumstances they did not choose and have little power to alter (10).
There are no easy answers to the questions of responsibility Elliott raises, but her reporting highlights the nature of Agency Intervention and Surveillance as a double-edged sword: Governmental help is necessary if families like Dasani’s are to have any chance at escaping The Lingering Effects of Poverty, but when that help comes with onerous requirements and constant surveillance, it can do far more harm than good.
Books on Justice & Injustice
View Collection
Class
View Collection
Class
View Collection
Contemporary Books on Social Justice
View Collection
Education
View Collection
Inspiring Biographies
View Collection
Loyalty & Betrayal
View Collection
Politics & Government
View Collection
Poverty & Homelessness
View Collection
Pulitzer Prize Fiction Awardees &...
View Collection
Sociology
View Collection
The Best of "Best Book" Lists
View Collection