29 pages • 58 minutes read
Katherine Anne PorterA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
The titular flowering Judas tree is the most prominent symbol in the short story. It appears twice: first, when Laura tries to dissuade the suitor outside her window, and second, in Laura’s nightmare when she eats the flowers from Eugenio. The flowering Judas tree itself is named for Judas Iscariot, the betrayer of Christ, who allegedly hung himself from a tree in remorse. The flowering Judas in this story takes on multiple meanings. In the first instance, the flower Laura throws is meant to say “no” to her suitor but only encourages him further. Here, the flower represents Laura’s contradictions, as she means to do one thing but instead does another. In the second occurrence, Laura greedily eats the flower, symbolizing the blood and body of Christ. However, in a macabre inversion of this religious rite, she is eating from the skeletal remains of Eugenio. This act represents multiple types of betrayal: to Laura herself, to her Catholic faith, to the revolutionary ideals she has supported, and to humanity.
In “Flowering Judas,” the motif of food and eating intersects with several of the story’s central ideas. Bottom of Form Braggioni’s over-indulgence in food (evident in the many references to his obesity) illustrates his self-indulgence. The revolutionary leader’s greed conflicts with his purported ideals; he is described as “swell[ing] with ominous ripeness” (Paragraph 7). This figurative comparison to fruit that is ripe to the point of decaying emphasizes Braggioni’s corruption. The leader’s corpulence is contrasted with his hungry followers, who “blow the foul breath from their empty stomachs in his face” (Paragraph 26). His greed is also juxtaposed with Laura’s self-denial in the name of the cause, illustrated when she dines on a plate of rice, and a cup of chocolate as Braggioni sings to her.
Food, eating, and hunger are intertwined with religious symbolism throughout the narrative. As Braggioni reconciles with his wife, he admits to being hungry and suggests they eat together. His hunger reflects a desire for love and forgiveness, evoking the concept of eating as a form of communion. The Christian symbolism of Holy Communion is more explicitly referenced in Laura’s dream at the end of the story. When Eugenio urges Laura to eat the Judas Flowers, declaring, “This is my body and my blood” (Paragraph 41), his words echo the rite of Holy Communion. Laura’s previous abstemiousness is replaced by an overwhelming “hunger and thirst” as she eats the flowers (Paragraph 6). This hunger is driven by her loss of faith (religious and political) and yearning for spiritual fulfillment. However, when Eugenio accuses Laura of cannibalism, he presents the act as a violation rather than an act of spiritual sustenance. The accusation evokes Eve’s consumption of the forbidden fruit in the Bible and reminds Laura she has betrayed her ideals. This final image suggests that Laura is unlikely to quench her spiritual hunger and thirst in Mexico.
Laura’s use of the word “No” is a motif that occurs several times throughout the story. It is the “holy talismanic word” from which she draws her strength (Paragraph 22). The repetition of the word emphasizes the theme of Female Objectification and Oppression. Laura must continually say no to fend off the men who see her in purely sexual times. “No” also represents Laura’s emotional detachment from life. It symbolizes how “the very cells of her flesh reject knowledge and kinship in one monotonous word” (Paragraph 22). Her use of the word “No” in several scenarios encompasses Laura’s rejection of other people and her growing isolation from everything. In her dream, she says “[n]o” to Eugenio several times, initially refusing to follow him. Her final cry of “No!” as the story concludes underscores her continued reluctance to engage with the realities of life.
Song features throughout “Flowering Judas” as both Braggioni and the young minstrel attempt to seduce Laura with their music. However, the singing is not pleasant and lends itself to the story’s unsettling tone. Braggioni relentlessly plays music off-key, “the strings of the instrument complain[ing] like exposed nerves” (Paragraph 25). This discordant imagery captures the effect the songs have on Laura, who does not desire Braggioni’s attentions to begin with but cannot stop or subvert them. Braggioni is also described as “snarling a tune under his breath” and “balancing his paunch between his knees” while he sings “with tremendous emphasis, weighing his words” (Paragraphs 1, 7)—all descriptions that highlight his repulsiveness in Laura’s eyes. Similarly, the young man sings “like a lost soul for two hours, but Laura [can] think of nothing to do about it” (Paragraph 19). Though neither his song nor his presence jars Laura to the same extent as Braggioni’s, he is still an unwanted suitor, and Laura’s inability to escape his music turns a common romantic trope (serenading) into a reminder of Female Objectification and Oppression.
At the same time, the motif highlights Laura’s disengagement from the world around her. Her disinterest in music reflects her disinterest in romance, sex, or sensory experience of any kind (in contrast to the “gluttonous” and “swollen” Braggioni, Laura is described as “thin” and only expresses physical hunger in the closing nightmare).
By Katherine Anne Porter