logo

52 pages 1 hour read

Nguyễn Phan Quế Mai

Dust Child

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2023

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Themes

The Costs of War for the Vietnamese

Dust Child centers the experiences of Vietnamese people during the war, and its most important theme is the tragic and devastating repercussions of war on Việt Nam and its people. The novel specifically examines the poverty caused by war, the sexual exploitation of Vietnamese women, the plight of Amerasian children after the war, communist persecution of “collaborators,” and chemical warfare.

The French occupation of Việt Nam and the wars that followed had a devastating economic impact on the region. The novel shows that Trang and Quỳnh are driven to sex work in order to help their parents repay a sizeable debt. This plot point is rooted in the real-life history of Việt Nam: Small farmers like Trang’s parents struggled to make ends meet because the colonial government sought to exploit the Vietnamese. The war of the 1960s and 1970s further destabilized the region, and several young women turned to sex work to earn money. Trang’s madam tells her, “[E]very girl who enters this place says [no] at first, but trust me, you won’t be able to hold yourself back” (84); she ends up being right since the money for sex work was comparatively very generous in those lean times.

Thus, Vietnamese women were sexually exploited due to their economic circumstances. However, if they became pregnant, they were abandoned by their partners and shunned by Vietnamese society. Trang’s narrative embodies the stories of real-life women who faced similar struggles. She is abandoned after she becomes pregnant, and she knows that she will be stigmatized by her fellow Vietnamese since she has slept with an American soldier. She knows that no one would want to hire a woman who has sold herself to a Westerner. Many women in Trang’s position were forced to make the difficult choice to give their children up for adoption, although even that was a risk, as orphanages often closed and children were left to fend for themselves.

In the novel, Phong’s story becomes an embodiment of the difficulties faced by Amerasian children in postwar Việt Nam. Before leaving him at the orphanage, Trang worries that “if she abandon[s] her baby, [he] could become one of the Amerasian children scavenging at markets” (266). By the time Trang is pregnant, there are already Amerasian children who have been abandoned and are forced to fend for themselves, showing that several Vietnamese women have been in the same position as Trang and have been forced to give their children up. Phong does indeed become another one of these “scavenging” children, and he has the additional burden of being mixed race: His dark skin makes him a target for colorism and racial prejudice. In this way, the novel highlights how the related issues of sexual exploitation and abandonment impacted the lives of Vietnamese women and children.

Although the impact of sexual exploitation and the plight of Amerasian orphans are focal points in Dust Child, the novel also sheds light on other ways in which the war impacted Vietnamese people. It makes numerous mentions of communist persecution of “collaborators” with the South Vietnamese and American militaries. It also discusses the re-education camps that many Vietnamese citizens were sent to after the war in order to instill in them an “appreciation” for communist values. These indoctrination centers were brutal places where violence was common. Phong spends time at one such camp, and the experience leaves him scarred. The war stoked anti-American sentiment in Việt Nam, and the American army’s presence there for so many years made the situation even worse for anti-communist Vietnamese since they were considered to be aligning themselves with the hated outsiders.

Part of why anti-American sentiment remained so high during these years was because of atrocities committed by the American military while they were in the country. Civilian casualties were high because American soldiers were encouraged to view civilians as potential spies and thus legitimate military targets. Civilians also suffered due to chemical warfare. Chemicals such as Agent Orange were dropped from airplanes in order to deforest dense areas of jungle and make North Vietnamese soldiers easier to see. However, the chemicals killed countless civilians, many children among them, and caused lasting damage that led to cancer and other disorders even decades after the war ended. Dan and Linda visit an orphanage that cares for children who were victims of Agent Orange, and this grounds the novel within the history of the war, showing the country’s lasting postwar damage.

Imperialism and War

The role that imperialism played in the Việt Nam war of the 1960s and 1970s is one of the novel’s most important themes and sets it apart from the first wave of literature written about Việt Nam. Literature published in the West during the decades that followed the war grappled with the cost of war for American soldiers, medical personnel, and journalists, but they did not typically delve deeply into the experiences of the Vietnamese. They also failed to engage with the ways in which the West stoked the flames of war in Southeast Asia. On the other hand, Dust Child examines the way that French colonialism set the stage for war in Việt Nam, and it also holds the United States accountable for its own imperialist foreign policy agenda within the region.

In the novel, Dan’s sections are set in 2016, and these show that the remnants of French colonization are still visible in Việt Nam. The novel uses French architecture, food, and culture to introduce the idea that France’s impact on Vietnamese culture and history can still be felt in the present day. This motif provides a segue to discuss the way that French colonial rule set up the country for civil war. It is Linda who first notices evidence of French culture in Sài Gòn, and her observations prompt Dan to reflect on the role of the French in the region, thinking about “the terrible things the French had done to the Vietnamese. They’d colonized the country for decades, divided its people, caused the first Indochina war, which killed hundreds of thousands of people” (70). After returning from the war, Dan made an effort to educate himself about Việt Nam and its people, which is why he is aware of the impact of French colonialism. He read about the history of French involvement in the region and came to the realization that colonialism had not been an effort to “bring civilization” to underdeveloped regions but a project of exploitation and control. He realizes that imperialism is about power, not civility. The French had very little respect for their colonial subjects and treated their colony as a resource to be controlled; as a result, they kept it suspended in a state of poverty and inequality. Their colonial project ultimately did little other than plant the seeds of civil war.

Dan further realizes that the disrespect and dehumanization that had characterized French colonial rule in Việt Nam was also evident in American attitudes toward the region. When he was a soldier, he was taught that the Vietnamese were a bellicose people who placed scant value on human life, and that characterization was used to justify the killing of not only Vietnamese soldiers but also civilians. The American army was “protecting” the Southern Vietnamese from their uncivilized northern neighbors and safeguarding democracy in the region. However, after he left Việt Nam, Dan learned that this idea was demonstrably false. Vietnamese people valued their own lives and the lives of their family members just as much as their American counterparts. America had not been “protecting” the Vietnamese, but rather meddling in their affairs to stop the spread of communism. The United States government wanted to prevent Russia and China from gaining more power on the world stage, and its support for the South Vietnamese army was not rooted in respect at all. The novel shows the suffering caused because of the atrocities committed by American forces on Vietnamese people and land.

American Soldiers’ Postwar Trauma

PTSD has long been a thematic focal point of literature about the Việt Nam War. Although Dust Child centers the experiences of Vietnamese soldiers and civilians, it also engages with the impact of PTSD on American GIs, primarily through its characterization of Dan and his narrative arc. However, the novel examines PTSD through a new lens: Rather than focusing solely on the way that Dan comes to grips with his trauma, it locates the roots of Dan’s PTSD and his horrific wartime experiences within a set of racist, imperialist attitudes toward the Vietnamese. The wartime atrocities that so scarred Dan were only possible because of the prejudice and hubris of the Americans. Further, it places blame on Dan and other American soldiers for having been the perpetrators of those atrocities, and it posits that closure and redemption can only be found in actual, tangible atonement.

The novel shows that Dan’s wartime actions—which continue to haunt him for decades after the war—were the direct result of American prejudice and American policy. Dan was part of a generation of young men sent to fight in a country about which they had little understanding; also, the war’s primary motives were obscured from them. Soldiers like Dan were taught that the Vietnamese were uncivilized and lacked respect for human dignity; they were told that their purpose in the country was to “save” it. Dan recalls having been “brainwashed” and told “that [they] were fighting people that were subhuman” (61). Because Dan and others like him did not understand the country or its history, they were unprepared for the kind of warfare they were about to engage in. Since they were taught that Vietnamese people were “subhuman,” they were encouraged to commit the very atrocities that would scar them emotionally for life. Dan, like many other soldiers— and particularly helicopter pilots—in Việt Nam, ended up killing innocent children, and he is unable to recover from the trauma of what he’s done.

The novel also points out that the emotional burden Dan carries from the war is rooted in the trauma caused by his own behavior. Dan is guilty not only of wartime atrocities on the battlefield but also of the disrespect and disregard that he shows Trang, whom he knows as “Kim.” He sees her as a diversion and sexually exploits her despite their long-term relationship. The very fact that he never bothers to ask for her real name, or even her last name, evidences his lack of interest in seeing Trang as a complex, multi-faceted human. This disregard for her humanity allows him to abandon her when she is pregnant with his child. Although Dan spends a substantial portion of the novel denying his guilt, he ultimately realizes that he was wrong to leave Trang alone and pregnant.

Toward the novel’s conclusion, Dan realizes that he must work to actively atone for his wartime actions by helping Việt Nam and its people; in this way, he finds a path forward from his guilt and trauma. Dan initially wants to find “Kim” out of a mixture of regret and curiosity, but it is only after speaking with Thiên and Phong that he realizes that he must do more than that: He has to find a way to atone for the sins that he committed during his year as a soldier. He maintains a connection with Phong and his family in part because he feels an affinity for the man whose aunt he once loved but also because Trang is dead and their daughter’s whereabouts are unknown. Phong remains the only person connected to his time in Việt Nam whom he can tangibly help, and the assistance that he and Linda provide to Phong, Bình, and their children becomes the primary way that Dan can begin to make up for the harm that he committed. Dan and Linda also visit an orphanage for children harmed by Agent Orange, and this is another instance in which Dan tries to perform tangible acts of service in hopes of redemption. Dan is not absolved by his guilt alone but through his actions.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Related Titles

By Nguyễn Phan Quế Mai