26 pages • 52 minutes read
Ralph Waldo EmersonA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Ralph Waldo Emerson is the best known adherent and writer on Transcendentalism. In fact, the clearest enunciation of Transcendentalism is from Emerson’s essay Nature (1836), published roughly two years before his speech. This philosophical system emphasizes an appreciation for nature that informs a correct understanding of man’s soul. It argues that society has slowly stripped away the “wholeness” of man and that solitude within in nature is the means to restore it. This developed from the artistic and intellectual movement of Romanticism, which revolved around appreciation of nature and the elevation of individual subjectivity. Emerson interchanges the idea of God with a Universal Being, which man may find by looking into the spirit of nature and one’s own spirit.
The inseparability of man and nature is a core tenant of Nature. The universe and what’s in it act as one entity. Therefore, when we look into our soul and rely on our intuitions, we are effectively looking into the reality of nature, as well. Man and his soul, along with all created things, are all aspects of the single entity that Emerson calls the Universal Being.
These ideas can be seen as a precursor to the arguments made in “Divinity School Address.” He argues that “the world is not the product of manifold power, but of one will, of one mind; and that one mind is everywhere active, in each ray of the star, in each wavelet of the pool” (4). It was his application of these philosophies into Christian thought that caused a stir among Unitarians.
Emerson was just one of many notable intellectuals who formed this movement. In 1836, the Transcendental Club was founded in Cambridge, Massachusetts, and it included the essayist and philosopher Henry David Thoreau, the feminist activist Sophia Ripley, the journalist Margaret Fuller, and many other prominent writers, artists, and philosophers. The name itself came from critics of the movement, who saw its ideas as unreasonable. Many of Emerson’s contemporaries, including Edgar Allen Poe and Nathaniel Hawthorne, wrote satirically of the movement.
The greater Boston area at the time of Emerson’s speech was overwhelmingly Unitarian, making it the dominant theology of the Divinity School during this time. They considered themselves nontrinitarians, believing God to be a unified entity instead of existing in three distinct persons, known as the doctrine of the Trinity. While Unitarians believed that Christ was sent by God and in direct communion with him, they denied Christ as God’s equal. Additionally, they rejected the theology of “original sin” (all humans are born into sinfulness) and the inerrancy of the Bible (the Bible is directly inspired by God and therefore free of errors). Compared to other denominations at the time, Unitarian theology was considered “liberal.”
Unitarian congregations first appeared in America in Boston in 1782, which became the hotbed of Unitarian thought for a century. After Unitarian theologian Henry Ware was appointed as Professor of Divinity at Harvard, the Divinity School shifted from its Calvinist roots (which emphasized God’s grace and the authority of the Bible) to teaching Unitarian theology.
Emerson was chosen by the graduating class to speak at their graduation as he was a former Unitarian minister and regular essayist and speaker on Unitarian ideas. Six of the seven graduating seniors were present for the speech, as well as Henry Ware, Divinity School Dean G. Palfrey, and Andrews Norton, considered colloquially as “the Unitarian Pope” for his outsized influence on the denomination. The negative responses to Emerson’s speech came from many of these well-known theologians. His ideas countered Unitarianism’s focus on reason and following the Bible; he favored having a natural and intensely human experience of God. Andrews Norton and Henry Ware specifically responded with sermons and essays denouncing Emerson and Transcendentalism. Regardless, Emerson made an impact on Unitarian thought, and Divinity Hall, where the infamous address was made, is also called Emerson Chapel.
By Ralph Waldo Emerson