36 pages • 1 hour read
Joy HarjoA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
In the epigraph, Harjo describes the east as the direction of beginnings, where the sun rises and where living beings orient themselves for beginnings. Harjo notes that east is also the direction of Oklahoma, where lies the Creek Nation where she was born.
Harjo describes a pivotal moment as a toddler in the backseat of her father’s black Cadillac driving in Tulsa in blazing heat. Tulsa is a Creek Indian town established in the mid-1800s at the end of the Trail of Tears. She focuses on a line of music a jazz trumpeter plays on the radio and follows that sound “to the birth of sound” (17), leading her to grieve the failings of her parents and her own life. She considers this moment her “rite of passage into the world of humanity” (17), through jazz music. Harjo describes this place as the “ancestor realm,” and she refers to it as the spiritual realm in other parts of the book.
Her mother is half Cherokee, half Irish. Her father is from the Creek, or Mvskoke, Nation, the descendant of a tribal leader, but he has no living father or grandfather to guide him. Harjo remembers herself in the spiritual realm before she was born and that she was attracted to the world by her mother’s voice and singing. She was born already with the purpose and plan to bring stories, songs, and art into the world. We all have our purpose and our responsibility in this world, and in this way she is not special, Harjo writes.
Harjo reflects on the many voices she hears as she writes of those who want their stories told. Ancestors want to have their stories recognized and remembered. She remembers her great grandfather Henry Marcy Harjo, a Seminole who became wealthy through his ownership of an oilfield in Oklahoma, and Harjo’s grandmother Naomi Harjo, who was well-educated in art at Oklahoma City University. Her early death from tuberculosis when Harjo’s father was a small child left a lifelong sadness in him. She notes that such “gulfs of sadness” often lead people to short-term distractions (22), including drugs and alcohol. The oil money Harjo’s father received supported his love for fine cars, including his black Cadillac and Ford pickup.
Harjo describes witnessing from the spiritual realm her mother and father meeting at a dance hall, describing her mother as fire and her father as water. Because Harjo is born “to earth, of water and fire,” she is able “to enter and emerge from ancestor realms” (25). She translates these spiritual experiences through poetry. She notes the hardship of being born for the newborns themselves and describes her own birth as a fight, noting that she wanted out. She was dying and hooked to a ventilator after her birth. She notes that this is a theme in her life, a “struggle with transitions” (29), such as beginnings and endings. Her father died with the same “dying, gulping breaths” as she was born with (30).
When Harjo was a young child, her mother was a beautiful, vivacious woman who took care of Harjo and the house with grace and joy. Her father is described as more distant and mysterious, but mostly loving. She recounts a story in which her father returned drunk one night when she was a baby and threatened to kill her mother.
At four, Harjo was rushed to the hospital during the polio epidemic and had an excruciatingly painful spinal tap. She emphasizes the pain of her mother and father being ripped away as her protectors, replaced by unknown doctors and nurses. The test shows she does not have polio. She begins having a recurring dream of being dragged into the water by an alligator and becoming an alligator herself. She believes the alligators cured her of polio.
She describes helping her mother dress up in fine clothes for a party, noting the childlike awe and fascination with such things. Her father carries a flask of liquor. Harjo notes how fragile the beauty of her mother is, occasionally being ruined by the drunken violence of her father.
Harjo uses a dream of ancient Egypt as an illustration of her vibrant dream life. She states that she still feels “more awake in my dreaming life than I [do] in this corporeal reality” (45). Yet when she went to public school and began attending an evangelical church, she stopped traveling through “story realms.” Such imagination and vision, “especially in girls or women, was evil and most likely of the devil” (45-46). She recounts how the children in her kindergarten class would copy each other, until she asked them why, and then they began to copy her. For Harjo, it is different; “drawing [is] dreaming on paper” (48). She realizes that her imagination and attraction to art is different from everyone else.
She also begins to notice the oppression of women and girls in society by the Church, as she is forced to put on a shirt while playing outside with her brother at five years old, while her brother is not. This realization leads her to adopt a feminist outlook in her life and art, although she does not use the term “feminist” herself.
At school, she also learns to read and discovers books and poetry. For Harjo, poetry is “to disappear into many dream worlds” (50). Poetry helps Harjo cope with her parents’ divorce. Her father became too violent due to alcohol and cheated with too many women. Harjo “dove into the other realm” of poetry and stories to cope (51). She relives a comforting memory of herself on her father’s lap at a family party, counting the rhythm of his heartbeat. Then she relives her fear when her father was angry, because she was not brave.
The structure of Harjo’s memoir is broadly chronological, but within each part, she frequently jumps forward and backward through time. This is particularly true of Part 1, which reads almost as a stream-of-consciousness collection of memories, stories, and anecdotes. Some are Harjo’s own memories from her young childhood, some are stories from her parents or other relatives, some are ancestral stories, and some are mysterious stories and memories she carries from the spiritual realm before she was born. The wandering style and pace of Part 1 gives it an informal, conversational tone.
As the epigraph at the beginning of Part 1 makes clear, this part is focused on beginnings. She opens the memoir not with her birth or her memories before birth, but with the memory of her first realization of the power of music. The fact that she chooses to begin the narrative with this anecdote signals the critical importance of creative art to Harjo throughout her life. From there she recounts her father’s beginnings by informing the reader of his ancestry and how he ended up an alcoholic drifting through life. She also tells the story of how her parents’ relationship began at a dance hall. Having laid the foundation for her own story by briefly recounting the stories of her parents, she tells the story of her own beginning—her birth. She also tells the important anecdote of being scolded by her mother to put a shirt on, which marks the inception of her feminist perspective and recognition of a male-dominated society.
The focus on beginnings in Part 1, symbolized by the eastern direction, is part of a narrative structural device that Harjo uses throughout the memoir. As the beginning of the story, it is natural that Part 1 would focus on beginnings and introductions. More fundamentally, however, the childhood that Harjo describes in Part 1 forms the basis that her life in the rest of the memoir is judged against. The generally positive memories and tone paint an image of an idyllic, pleasant childhood. Her internal image of this idealized household leads her to unconsciously attempt to recreate this household in her adult life, although she succeeds only in recreating the dysfunctional aspects of it. The beginnings that Harjo establishes are thus critically important, and by the end of the memoir, she realizes that she must release herself from her past in order to move forward.
When negative memories, such as her father’s drunken threat to her mother, are presented, Harjo portrays them matter-of-factly and dismisses them quickly. She mostly portrays her father as a benevolent, comforting figure. When her mother divorces him, Harjo recalls a reassuring memory of sitting on his lap as a young girl at a party, noting the rhythm of his heartbeat. This intimate connection between them makes their separation after the divorce all the more wrenching, and it suggests that this separation leads to her attraction to similar men in her adolescence and adulthood.
In important moments, Harjo often adds weight and evokes emotional responses by drawing on the spiritual realm or ancestral stories and on personal emotions tied to her parents. She uses this approach, for example, in telling the story of her birth. First she develops dramatic weight to this story by portraying her memories of the mystical spiritual realm before birth, and she makes her birth to her mother more emotional by describing how the sound of her mother’s singing attracted her to earth from this realm.
Harjo characterizes her younger self as deeply spiritual through her consistent use of dreams and memories of the spiritual realm as well as her knowledge of other times and places. While telling the story of her birth, Harjo focuses much more attention on her experiences in the spiritual realm than on the birth itself. Dreams in which she experiences herself in ancient Egypt or as an alligator likewise establish her profound spirituality and imagination. She also characterizes herself as artistic and intensely creative by emphasizing her love of music and art as a child. It is important that her spirituality and her creativity are established as her major characteristics, as moving forward in the memoir, she begins to lose both of these. Thus, the major conflict of the narrative is established in Part 1 through Harjo’s characterization of herself.
By Joy Harjo