logo

64 pages 2 hours read

Mary Downing Hahn

Closed for the Season

Fiction | Novel | Middle Grade | Published in 2009

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more. For select classroom titles, we also provide Teaching Guides with discussion and quiz questions to prompt student engagement.

Chapters 5-8Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 5 Summary

Logan arrives home and sees Johnny O’Neil mowing their lawn. Logan revels in the smells and sounds of summer before going to show his mother the photocopy of the newspaper article. He tells her all about Nina Stevens and they both head inside to show Logan’s dad. Mr. Forbes is busy talking to a contractor about a new roof. He does not believe they should pursue a complaint against the realtor for their lack of transparency.

The next morning, Arthur arrives as Logan is eating breakfast. Nina Stevens will be by both of their homes today to interview their guardians. Nina soon arrives to chat with Mrs. Jenkins and the boys follow them into the house. Logan ogles Mrs. Jenkins’s decorations because the house is filled with miniature figures and paintings of clowns. During the interview, Mrs. Jenkins fervently supports Mrs. Donaldson’s innocence while blaming Silas Phelps for her murder. According to Mrs. Jenkins, Mrs. Donaldson and Silas had a feud due to his mistreatment of her daughter Violet. Violet frequently brought her children to her mother’s home to escape Silas’s wrath. When the police questioned Silas about his whereabouts during the murder, Violet corroborated his alibi. Though Silas is now in prison, Mrs. Jenkins is positive that he will be out soon. Violet now lives in a mobile home on the Phelps property with her children. Nina jots down this information because she wants to interview Violet as well.

Nina then asks Mrs. Jenkins to recommend a tour guide; though Arthur ecstatically volunteers, she wishes to have a guide above the age of eighteen. Nina then takes pictures of the Jenkinses, Bear, and the home. Afterward, Nina goes over to Logan’s home where she speaks with his parents. She also disappears into the attic where she looks through the things that Mrs. Donaldson left behind. Nina speaks with Logan’s parents to get their thoughts on the case before leaving. Arthur suggests that they ride their bikes to the Magic Forest after lunch.

Chapter 6 Summary

After lunch and an incident involving Arthur and some fancy cookies, Logan and Arthur make their way to the Magic Forest. As they ride their bikes, a group of five boys their age accosts them. One of the boys shames Arthur for the state of his bike and begins taunting and bullying them. Danny, the primary bully, is Mrs. Donaldson’s grandson. Johnny notices the scene and stops the boys from escalating the situation any further. Logan’s knee is scraped and bleeding from the incident. Arthur discovers that Johnny gave the reporter Billy Jarmon’s number so that he could be her tour guide. Arthur calls Billy a bum and Johnny warns him to watch his mouth.

Afterward, Logan and Arthur continue their ride to the Magic Forest. Danny Phelps is Arthur’s “number-one enemy” and Arthur goes on to tell Logan how dumb the entire Phelps clan is (42). Both Danny and Arthur used to play together when they were little, before Mrs. Donaldson died. The landscape around them gets more and more rural as they bike towards the amusement park. Over an hour later, Arthur speeds down a hill with his hands up in the air. After hiding their bikes in a mass of kudzu vines, they enter the jungle and eventually sneak through a gap in the fence into the amusement park. 

Chapter 7 Summary

As they begin exploring the park, Logan and Arthur begin discussing the comic strip “Zippy the Pinhead” (46). Arthur is convinced that Logan is simply not smart enough to get the humor, but the latter insists he is just as smart as Arthur. They crawl into the mouth of Willie the Whale, a giant fiberglass figure that has been spray painted over the years. While Arthur regales Logan with past experiences at the Magic Forest, Logan hears someone approaching. Logan is terrified and is unable to stop thinking about his mother’s warnings about “lonely places” (47). Just then, they realize that the people they heard were just Nina and Billy. According to Arthur, Billy has already been to jail at least twice. They overhear snippets of Nina and Billy’s conversation. Billy believes that the money is still on the amusement park property. They also hear Billy warn Nina about Mr. DiSilvio, the owner of the park property and the father of the town realtor. 

Arthur and Logan reveal themselves to Nina and Billy; the man is furious at the sight of them. Arthur and Billy begin arguing about the safety of the park but Nina steps in. Nina suggests that Billy give the boys a ride home and he reluctantly agrees to meet them and their bikes at the front gate. It begins to rain. 

Chapter 8 Summary

Logan asks why Arthur provokes Billy on purpose, to which the boy replies that Billy is “a despicable ignoramus” (53). They meet the adults at the front gate with their bikes and get into the pickup truck just as it begins to rain. Arthur begins talking about the Aesir and Thor, the god of thunder; he mocks Billy for not knowing anything about it. Billy threatens to make Arthur walk home, and the boy finally begins to quiet down. Billy eventually drops them both back at home with their bikes. Arthur’s grandmother calls him inside and when Logan heads home, he “got a long lecture on the importance of telling people where [he] was going and when [he] was coming back” (56).

As Logan is eating dinner, his father warns him not to go to the Magic Forest. Later that night, he overhears his parents talking about him. Rhoda, the realtor, has apparently told Logan’s mother not to let him befriend Arthur. Logan’s father distrusts Rhoda and says as much, supporting Logan’s friendship with Arthur. Logan smiles to himself and seems, for the first time, genuinely excited by the adventures that he and Arthur will have together.

Chapters 5-8 Analysis

Chapters Five through Eight continue to develop previous themes that were established in the last section. Hahn continues to deepen the mystery as well, finally introducing the readers and Logan to the abandoned amusement park at the heart of both the novel and the investigation. With kudzu vines covering the secret entrance into the park—a mere hole in the fence—and everything plastered with graffiti and litter, the Magic Forest appears somehow both more magical and infinitely more decrepit.

Located far out of town, an hour away by bike, Hahn continues to set the rural scene in Bealesville. The tone of loneliness and isolation is omnipresent in this section, an echo to Logan’s initial uncertainty about both moving to a new town and his reluctance to be friends with Arthur. Though the reader has yet to meet Violet, she is presented as a crucial character, a key to the mystery. She is connected to both Mrs. Donaldson, her mother, and Silas, her husband. Violet is at the center of this mystery.

Class differences are clearly drawn. There appears to be a hierarchy in Bealesville, with families such as the DiSilvios who live in new developments like Fair Oaks at the very top. The Forbeses appear to land somewhere in the middle, with the Jenkinses beneath them, and families like the Phelpses, Jarmons, and O’Neils at the very bottom. Most clearly, Arthur gives away his lower class status when he reveals his beaten bicycle, when he repeatedly asks Logan to pay for their photocopies at the library, and when he unknowingly consumes a large number of Mrs. Forbes’s expensive cookies. Arthur is unfamiliar with the cookies and their cost. Likewise, he expects Logan to have money, and though he promises to pay him back, never does.

Despite being less fortunate, Arthur believes himself to be smarter than most other people, including Logan. Interestingly enough, however, Arthur seems to be most dismissive of the Phelpses’ intelligence, especially Danny. He dismisses them, the Jarmons, and the O’Neils as the “worst families in town,” and cites his grandmother who believes “they're directly descended from Cain” (28). The question of wealth undoubtedly surrounds this novel. Not only in the missing money from the Magic Forest, but also in the sharp class differences between many of the residents. Some people want to save the amusement park to keep the local charm and character of Bealesville, while others want chains like Wal-Mart to enter town to provide more opportunities for economic growth.  

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text