logo

74 pages 2 hours read

Kamila Shamsie

Burnt Shadows

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2009

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 3, Chapters 17-20Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 3: “Part-Angel Warriors”

Part 3, Chapter 17 Summary

Kim Burton, Harry’s 15-year-old American daughter, rides with Harry through Islamabad on a visit. Harry and Kim’s mother are divorced, and Harry and Kim’s relationship is strained by Harry’s professional need for secrecy. Kim says that Harry is happier in Islamabad than in New York City. Harry tells Kim that he hates the place but loves the people. Harry remembers being bullied at his English boarding school for being half-German and how he eventually found friends among his more diverse classmates in America when he moved to New York to be with his mother, Ilse.

Harry reassures Kim that he misses her, but Kim is annoyed by Harry’s commitment to his cover story even in their private moments and tells him, “Drop the consular-officer crap, Dad” (174). Harry, worried that his car is bugged, pulls over and demands Kim apologize, which she does, ashamed that her teenage attitude could cause her to endanger her father. Harry struggles with his own shame over the fact that although he misses his daughter, he is living exactly the life he wants to live. At first an idealistic recruit to the CIA, Harry grew to appreciate the excitement of the job more than his belief in America as a superpower “nation of migrants” (175).

Briefly, Harry regrets not taking Kim to meet Hiroko, Sajjad, and Raza, but he is nervous about how Raza and Kim would get along. Kim asks Harry to pull over so she can talk to a contractor building a mosque. As Harry watches Kim’s enthusiasm for the construction, he reflects on his father James’s relationship to a failing empire and his own desire to end Communism compared to Kim’s dream of building something new.

Part 3, Chapter 18 Summary

With Kim now back in America, Harry goes to the beach with Hiroko, Sajjad, and Raza. Hiroko teases Harry about his dyed hair, which is for Harry’s cover as a Pathan Afghan man, for which he uses the alias “Lala Buksh.”

Hiroko tells Harry about the elaborate fairy tales she created to abstract the horror of Nagasaki but says that she was never able to tell them to Raza or show Raza her scars. Harry recalls that the only issue when he applied to the CIA was his belief that America should never have dropped the nuclear bombs. Harry feels awkward at pushing Hiroko to discuss her past, but Hiroko assures Harry that she lives without survivor’s guilt and is grateful for her rekindled friendship with Ilse, whom she now talks to by phone. Harry marvels at all that Hiroko and Sajjad have overcome, and Hiroko admits that Raza may have a harder time overcoming obstacles because he has faced fewer of them. After the second failed exam, Sajjad made Raza come to work in the soap factory, hoping to frighten Raza into pursuing college. Hiroko tells Harry about Raza’s test anxiety.

Hiroko and Sajjad go walking on the beach while Harry talks to Raza. Raza, who now calls the American “Uncle Harry,” is delighted that Harry remembered to bring him the marshmallows he asked for, as Raza plans to use them to impress Bilal’s older sister, Salma. Harry invents a story about Kim having test anxiety to make Raza feel better and promises to teach Raza test-taking strategies, using the possibility of attending university in America as motivation and suggesting that Raza could earn a scholarship. Harry tells Raza, “In America, everyone can be American” (189). Harry briefly considers that Raza—ethnically ambiguous, desperate for purpose, and gifted with languages—would be an ideal CIA recruit. 

Part 3, Chapter 19 Summary

Raza calls Salma to tell her that he got her marshmallows from New York, as promised. As their relationship has never gone beyond secret phone calls, Raza insists that Salma meet him in person to collect the marshmallows, but Salma demurs. Raza tries to impress Salma by announcing that his Uncle Harry is going to help him get into an American university and jokingly suggests that Salma marry him and come to America, too. Salma tells Raza that her parents would never let her marry him because of Hiroko’s history in Nagasaki. The parents in the neighborhood are all too afraid that Hiroko’s radiation exposure will result in unhealthy babies and are worried that Raza may be secretly “deformed.”

Salma hangs up, and Raza is devastated by the rejection. Raza considers that Salma would be allowed to marry Raza’s cousin Altamash, who recently visited Karachi and was immediately more popular than Raza. Raza was also upset that people assumed Altamash, and not Raza, was Sajjad’s son, because of Raza’s Japanese features. Raza even considers his German middle name, Konrad, as another factor that makes him a foreigner in his own home. Raza resolves to take the college entry exam again and to go to an American university after all. 

Part 3, Chapter 20 Summary

Chapter 20 opens on Raza standing in the doorway of Hiroko and Sajjad’s room as Sajjad lies on the bed in deep distress, then flashes back to the night before, when Harry comes to dinner at the Ashrafs’ to celebrate Raza’s decision to take the exams a third time. Raza wears the cashmere jacket, which he jokingly offers to return to Harry. Raza announces that Harry promised to get an American university to pay his tuition. Harry clarifies that he only promised to help Raza with test strategies and that he can’t promise that Raza will be accepted or earn a scholarship. Harry explains that the test Raza failed, Islamic Studies, isn’t necessary for admission to American schools and that he encouraged Raza to retake the test so that Raza could also have options for university locally. Sajjad compares Harry’s promises to James’s promises to make Sajjad a lawyer and throws Harry out of the house.

The next morning, Raza accidentally breaks Sajjad’s tape recorder, one of his most prized possessions. Desperate to please his father, Raza goes to Sohrab Goth to buy a new tape recorder at the flea market. Raza searches the slums for Abdullah, hoping he can help him barter with the merchants. Raza finds Abdullah and evades his questions with a cover story: Raza claims to be an orphaned Afghan refugee who made an oath never to speak of his past until the Soviets leave Afghanistan. Abdullah believes Raza’s story and welcomes Raza as a brother. Raza asks Abdullah for help bartering, but Abdullah assumes that Raza wants to buy weapons, which Abdullah helps smuggle into mujahideen training camps. Abdullah promises to teach Raza how to handle an AK-47 if Raza tells him what Harry was doing at the fish market. Raza covers by saying that there are other ways than guns to beat the Soviets, implying that he works with Harry and unwittingly hinting at Harry’s real role with the CIA. Abdullah asks Raza to teach him English, and Raza agrees.

Part 3, Chapters 17-20 Analysis

The personal and political tensions at play now well established, Shamsie begins to bring Harry and the Tanaka-Ashrafs closer together to set up the devastating impact of Raza’s disappointment and Sajjad’s murder to come, both as a result of Harry’s interventions. As previously explored in Part 2 with James’s advice to leave India for safety, even the best intentions of cross-cultural friendships sometimes play out in tragic ways because personal relationships do not exist outside the boundaries of geopolitical forces.

The struggle between nationalism and cosmopolitanism plays out in Harry’s interior life as he tries to help Raza achieve his potential but fails to consider how his words are heard by the younger man whose expectations are shaped by very different cultural norms. When Harry is accused of false promises at dinner, his defensiveness recalls James’s paternalistic attitudes toward Sajjad, as Harry mistakes cultural differences for childishness rather than considering that his words were not received as he intended them to be. Shamsie connects Harry’s failure to recognize the differences between impact and intent in cross-cultural relationships with his difficulty connecting to his daughter, Kim. Kim’s interest in building contrasted with Harry’s desire to tear down political forces he sees as threats to democracy emphasizes Shamsie’s portrayal of the generational shift at this point in the novel. Raza and Kim have a much more fluid understanding of the forces of good and evil in the world, being one more generation removed from World War II than Harry is. Harry can actually see Raza’s vulnerability at the beach—but his first reaction is to consider exploiting it by recruiting Raza to the CIA. Harry’s use of, effectively, brownface to assume the alias Lala Buksh also emphasizes Harry’s misguided sense of already living out the cosmopolitan ideals of his Uncle Konrad which he aspires to. Even as Harry proclaims that “everyone can be American” (189), he fails to consider the value proposition in that statement, which is that everyone should want to be American.

In Raza, Shamsie explores what happens when a longing to belong is taken to its worst conclusion, as opposed to Sajjad and Hiroko’s ability to forge new identities in the face of disconnection from home. Raza, frustrated by an inability to fit in that is totally out of his control, is too desperate to consider the consequences of impersonating an Afghan refugee. After Salma’s rejection, Raza thinks only about how “intersections were created from shared stories and common histories, from marriages and the possibilities of marriages” (193), and, excluded from the neighborhood he grew up in, he leaps at the first opportunity to be accepted. No matter how many languages he learns, Raza is unable to feel a sense of belonging until, like Ilse Weiss trying to fit in among the English, he translates himself, becoming Raza Hazara to earn Abdullah’s friendship. Later, Raza discovers the discomfort of only being accepted as a version of himself rather than being known and loved for who he truly is.

Hiroko still struggles to incorporate the trauma of Nagasaki into her personal narrative. Shamsie locates Hiroko’s fears about the future in the rising Islamic extremism in Pakistan, connecting nationalist movements across generations and borders by comparing it to the nationalism of WWII Japan. However, as Sajjad’s murder will soon reveal, the forces of nationalism from Hiroko’s past have only grown more complicated as political power has transferred from James Burton’s generation, which fought its wars out in the open, to Harry Burton’s generation, more entrenched in espionage and influenced by rising globalism after World War II. 

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text