logo

54 pages 1 hour read

Stephen Hawking

Brief Answers to the Big Questions

Nonfiction | Book | Adult | Published in 2018

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapter 6Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 6 Summary: “Is Time Travel Possible?”

A plane is two-dimensional and flat. On a plane, a triangle always has internal angles that add up to 180 degrees. A sphere is two-dimensional but curved; on a sphere, a triangle adds up to more than 180 degrees. Tiny, two-dimensional beings on a large sphere eventually would discover that large triangles on their sphere had inner angles that add up to more than 180 degrees. Likewise, our three-dimensional universe seems to be “flat,” and standard Euclidean geometry works fine everywhere. If, though, our three-dimensional universe is located on a four-dimensional sphere, we’d eventually find that our universe is curved.

Einstein, in his 1905 paper on special relativity, showed that space and time can be considered a four-dimensional unity—space-time—but that the time portion varies depending on how fast various observers are traveling relative to one another. His 1915 paper on general relativity proved that gravity warps space-time. For example, near the sun, light from nearby stars gets bent, so those stars’ positions appear to shift very slightly.

In addition, Einstein proved that, to travel as fast as light, a mass would need to be accelerated by an infinite force. This seems to rule out space travel at light speed or greater. It might, however, be possible to generate a “wormhole” that goes from one side of our galaxy to the other. Returning via a second wormhole might allow people to get home before they left.

Wormholes require immense negative mass and energy, which are hard to come by, though the uncertainty principle of quantum mechanics allows for this via virtual particles, which arise spontaneously in matched pairs and then disappear. Two metal plates, when sufficiently close, limit the type of virtual particles that can form between them. A greater number of virtual particles around those plates exerts a pressure on the plates. The energy density of the universe around the plates averages out to zero, so the energy density between the plates must be negative. This phenomenon, called the Casimir effect, has been demonstrated by scientists. Someday, people may be able to harness such energy to create wormholes.

If time travel is, indeed, possible, then perhaps someone should by now have come back to tell about it: “[I]t is difficult to believe that someone wouldn’t show off and tell us poor benighted peasants the secret of time travel” (137). Possibly, space-time hasn’t been warped enough to permit time travel but might become able to do so in the future. Folks from that time would be able to visit the past—but not so far back as to visit us. Any travel into the past could create paradoxes. For example, people might be able to kill their own ancestors and prevent themselves from being born.

One solution is that time travel to the past is possible only if it’s self-consistent; another is that quantum mechanics permits any number of possible timelines and that time travelers move along some of these lines but not others. M-theory, which contains 11 dimensions instead of four, might allow for time travel. The odds for any of these possibilities, though, seem low.

Chapter 6 Analysis

In this chapter, Hawking expands on the theme of Knowing the Universe Through Science (and alludes to the other two themes: The Dangers of Modernity and A Limitless Future) as he discusses the possibilities for faster-than-light travel, which might permit people to go back in time. Hawking is skeptical of this possibility but doesn’t rule it out.

The principal way by which people might travel across galactic distances in a short time is by using wormholes. These objects would be made of negative matter and energy, of which very little is available in the universe. A civilization much more technically sophisticated than ours might nevertheless manage to construct one.

Wormholes and time travel are the brainchild of physicist Kip Thorne, Hawking’s friend who wrote one of the introductions to this book. Thorne’s work on gravitational waves won him a Nobel prize, and his research on the use of negative mass and energy to construct wormholes has captured the imaginations of sci-fi writers and those who dream of advanced space travel.

Wormholes might make it possible to travel back in time. This creates paradoxes that Hawking believes the physics of our universe don’t permit. Basically, if we could travel back in time, we might be able to kill our forebears and thus extinguish ourselves. If we never existed, we wouldn’t have killed them, so we’d still be alive to go back and kill them and get extinguished again, in an endless, self-canceling loop that defies logic.

Sci-fi writer Robert Heinlein addresses similar time paradoxes in his short story “All You Zombies.” In the story, a person who has undergone sex reassignment surgery to become a man travels back in time and impregnates his earlier, female self, who gives birth to her/him, thus becoming his/her own mother and father. (An award-winning film version, Predestination, was released in 2014.) Whether such a scenario might be a workaround for the apparent impossibilities of time travel is debatable.

Some of Thorne’s research has attempted to prove that travel in wormholes can’t cause time paradoxes. If so, then something akin to the hyperspace travel in Star Trek and Star Wars may be possible. Thorne created the story idea for, and coproduced, the 2014 film Interstellar, which is about astronauts who travel through a wormhole to search for new planets. The film was popular and won 20 awards, including an Oscar for special effects.

The public has a big appetite for stories of hyperspace and time travel; it’s part of our yearning to see more of the universe, past and present. Hawking is skeptical about such possibilities but seems to share people’s enthusiasm for the topic. Such travel might be fraught with problems, but wishing for it is hard to resist.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text