logo

100 pages 3 hours read

Atia Abawi

A Land of Permanent Goodbyes

Fiction | Novel | YA | Published in 2018

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more. For select classroom titles, we also provide Teaching Guides with discussion and quiz questions to prompt student engagement.

Part 1, Chapters 6-10Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 1, Chapter 6 Summary

The next morning, Tareq awakens in Uncle Waleed’s house. His Aunt Nada is brewing coffee. Aunt Nada is married to Uncle Waleed, Fayed’s brother. Although they weren’t blood relations, Nada was very closer to Tareq’s mother, almost like a sister. Nada and Waleed have one son, Musa, who is just one year younger than Tareq. The small family is visibly impacted by the war, as all have grown thinner.

Nada tries to comfort Tareq, but he is having a difficult time. He has nightmares of the bombing at night and struggles with survivor’s guilt: “He felt guilty for even thinking about why his mother was gone but Musa still had his—but it was there, with all the other thoughts he tried to shake out of his head” (49). When Musa asks if Tareq can join him on a drive to the shop, Tareq seizes the opportunity to escape the house and “those sympathetic stares” (51).

Part 1, Chapter 7 Summary

Musa drives the boys to the shop. The car ride is an opportunity to provide a closer look at how Daesh control has changed Raqqa, and for Musa and Tareq to catch up on all that has happened in Syria. They pass abandoned homes and closed shops. Some families have fled the country, and when they go, Daesh spray paints their homes, claiming that the deserters were American spies. A “free-for-all” results, and others seize the homes. If the family comes back, they are killed.

Tareq notes that many of the Daesh men they pass don’t appear to be Syrians. Musa explains that, while there are some Syrians among them, many of the Daesh come from all over the world—France, Saudi Arabia, Tunisia, America, Kuwait, Britain, Libya, Iraq. He says the Iraqis are the worst and call the locals “kafers,” Arabic for non-believers. According to Musa, the Iraqis are mostly in charge because Daesh began in Iraq.

Musa notes that Daesh has little to do with Islam. Some of the foreigners from England even relied on Quran for Dummies instead of the actual Quran. Musa refers to the “Salafi cancer” (56). The term Salafi is often used to describe fundamentalist Islamic thought. Tareq is not familiar with this ideology. He has been taught that there are two main sects in Islam, Shia and Sunni. He is aware that there are conflicts between these two, but his parents shielded him from the details, and his mother referred to the differences as a political feud having nothing to do with religion.

Finally, the boys arrive at the shop. The boxes of hair dye—Nada asked Musa to get her some—have the female model’s faces blacked out with marker. The women’s faces being shown goes against the principles of Daesh. Musa jokes to the shop-owner whether the boxes of hair dye will get “lashes” if they don’t wear their niqabs. A niqab is a garment of clothing worn by some Muslim women to cover the face. The “lashes” refers to the lash of a whip or cane, a popular form of punishment inflicted by Daesh. The shop-owner warns Musa that he shouldn’t make such jokes; Daesh has spies everywhere.

As Musa and Tareq leave the shop, men of Daesh accost them. Tareq feels a rifle in his back, and a voice shouts, “Yallah!” (move on, go) in accented Arabic.

Part 1, Chapter 8 Summary

Tareq and Musa are terrified, worried they are going to be punished or executed. Instead, they are forced towards Naim Square. The Daesh are holding a public execution and want to make an example of their victim. Musa warns Tareq he must not cry, flinch, or show any emotion because spies of Daesh will be watching the crowd for anyone who may sympathize with the man being executed.

A young man is brought forward and his supposed offenses (for example, “insulting divinity” (63)) are read aloud. A member of Daesh holds up a black flag of Daesh, on which is written the shahada, the declaration of faith: “There is no God but God, and Muhammad is the Messenger of God” (64). The Daesh shoot, then decapitate the man. Both of his parents, forced to watch, fall to the ground, presumably in a faint or in grief. The crowd dissipates, and Tareq and Musa head back to the car. 

Part 1, Chapter 9 Summary

Tareq and Musa drive back to Waleed’s home. Musa notices a pickup truck is following them; men from Naim Square are inside, undoubtedly Daesh. Musa tells Tareq that when they get out at Waleed’s, they should go straight to the door and not make eye contact with the men. Inside, they tell the adults what has occurred. The doorbell rings, and Waleed says he will handle it. He instructs Tareq, Musa, and Fayed to wait inside.

As they wait, Fayed wonders what the men outside might want. Musa responds: “All I can think, Uncle, is the cubs of Daesh…I mean, I think we’re too old for it. But you never know with these guys” (70). Musa explains that Daesh has training camps for children, indoctrinating them—essentially brainwashing them—and teaching them how to use weapons. He’s heard of kids coming out and executing their own parents for not following the rules of Daesh.

Waleed returns. Everything is fine for now, he says, but Fayed, Tareq, and Susan must leave sooner than planned. The money Waleed took out earlier that day will be enough to get to them to Turkey, at least. He tells Musa that he will go with them. Musa says he doesn’t want to go without his parents, but Waleed insists and reassures Musa, saying they will reunite. Destiny points out that they will not. 

Part 1, Chapter 10 Summary

Chapter 10 is a monologue-style reflection from Destiny, similar to that seen in the “prologue.” Destiny reflects on the ways humans divide themselves through the creation of borders: “The invisible lines in your world hold so much power” (73). Destiny notes that borders are manmade and artificial, as no animal would pay attention to them. Setting up the story to come—Tareq’s leaving his homeland—Destiny concludes, “the journey beyond those invisible lines can become just as heinous as living inside the fire” (75). 

Part 1, Chapters 6-10 Analysis

Chapters 6 through 10 take a step back from Tareq’s story and offer a broader look at the situation in Syria. The dialogue between Tareq and Musa in the car ride to the shop in Chapter 7 offers valuable historical, religious, and geo-political context regarding Syria’s state and what led to it. The author uses Tareq’s “ignorance” in order to present details to the reader: As Tareq asks Musa questions, he feels “ashamed for not having read more about this instead of playing games on his computer” (56). 

For instance, Tareq notes that Salafism stems from Saudi Arabia and the Gulf region (referring to the Arab states of the Persian Gulf: Bahrain, Kuwait, Iraq, Oman, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, and the United Arab Emirates). He wonders why the men representing Daesh in Syria aren’t all Saudis. Musa says that, while many of the men are Saudis, the Salafi ideology has spread well beyond Saudi Arabia. Thanks to the country’s oil-rich wealth, they can print their propaganda in multiple languages. Opposing them is “President Assad, the Alawite, and his backing from Iran and the Shias” (56-57). Musa sums it up: “This is a proxy holy war being fought, and our lives—your family’s lives—used as martyrs!” (57). By presenting such details in the context of a conversation between two characters, the educational material in the young adult novel feels less like a lesson.

The lens of the story also has a wider perspective due to the change in location. With the journey to Raqqa—and the descriptions of Raqqa itself—the reader can better appreciate that the entire country is wracked by war. The brutality of the public execution and beheading in Naim Square is another reminder that Tareq and his family have not chosen to become refugees but are forced into this position. Musa’s character epitomizes the “reluctant refugee.” While Musa wants to stay in Raqqa with his parents, his father insists that he leave. Later in the book, Waleed and Nada will be killed, a fact that Destiny foreshadows: Waleed tries to assure Musa that they will reunite “But they all knew that might not be possible. And the truth is, I know so many families who have said the same thing with only sadness to meet them when I did. This family was no different” (72). It is another permanent goodbye.

Chapter 10 serves as a sort of interlude, as Tareq’s story is put on pause and the voice of Destiny is given a monologue. The omniscient narrator again reminds the reader of the fact that Tareq’s story is one of millions and sets up anticipation for the journey ahead, foreshadowing the difficulty that awaits the refugees. Even if they make it beyond Syria’s borders—which isn’t a guarantee—“the journey beyond those invisible lines can become just as heinous as living inside the fire” (75). It’s clear to the reader that Tareq’s journey will not get easier anytime soon. 

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text